In the next few months after my year end bonus, I'm probably gonna go with these:
4 New 265/70R16 Ironman All Country AT 265 70 16 Tires A/T | eBay
Find one of those regular 10+% eBay coupons and you can have them delivered to a local Firestone and mounted and balanced for barely over $400 total.
Owned by Cooper and have great reviews.