I was driving home from a great day of skiing on Friday when something came out of the darkness and hit the front of my 4Runner on Hwy 80. It looked sort of like a green apple or a tennis ball, but I don't think it was either of them. Normally this wouldn't be an issue but I'm missing the lower valance to my front bumper, so the lower half of the radiator is completely exposed.




Exposed Radiator



I have an OBD2 reader that has a display screen below my radio, so I turned it on and watched the temps for a minute, but it looked fine so I kept going. I got home and the only thing I could see was a very small mark on the radiator that could honestly have been there before.



Anyway, this got me thinking that it's high time to buy a bumper if only to protect my radiator. I've been meaning to for a while, but I like the look it has now, and I wasn't super eager about any of my three main choices:



1. TNF Alpha Bumper

I know it isn't super popular because there isn't any way to mount a winch, but I really like the low profile look and the way it really hugs the lines of the 4Runner. I've never needed a winch, but I can't help thinking about the possibilities in the distant future and wondering... (plus if I ever wanted to get rid of it, it would probably be more difficult for that reason. $995.95 shipped to me



2. 4xInnovations front plate bumper

In contrast, this one seems to be super popular. Winch possible, hi-lift jack points, beefier but still a pretty good look. I think that my main issue with this one is that it's 20 lbs heavier than the TNF at ≈100 lbs, and I think it's probably beefier than I'll ever need. Plus I don't think I'd mount a winch anyway for a very long time. edit: I also saw that the 4x bumper has had some issues with protecting the front end in a collision $914 shipped to me



3. OEM lower bumper valance

My 4Runner is a '99 but the PO didn't like the fat lip bumper so he swapped it for a '96-'98. I could buy the '96-'98 lower valance from a supplier near me for about $100, but I'm not sure it would fit, given that mine's a '99. It also doesn't seem like it offers the greatest protection since I think it's pretty much just a thick piece of plastic. pn: (53911-35909)



I have the CBI rear hybrid bumper from the PO (he cut off the hitch though), and I do really like it.



Any suggestions, input, thoughts, ruminations, etc. are welcome.