It depends on what you want...the "fancier" look of the Clazzios or more rugged function of the othe seat covers (still look good too IMO). I too was hard pressed to spend as much given that mine is well over 200k miles (235k) but I've always wanted a set so I ended up buying a perforated set of the Clazzios a year ago. Love them! The biggest reason I went with clazzio was for the brown seat color to contrast my blacked out interior. Besides of course their decent price and excellent fitment.

I mountain bike a lot so I'm always sweating on mine BUT I do typically change shirts and put down a towel too if I'm extremely muddy so YMMV.

If easy to clean is your only/main goal, I'd get something smooth and skip the perforated option either way.