The gaskets are V shaped, and should be inserted in such a way that the V is upside down when the covers are in place. So it should look like this:
The ^s are the gasket and the | | is the tube.
I realize this is kinda counter intuitive as the V being upside down makes them harder to fit on to the spark plug tube - but that is how they go. The V being the other way would allow oil under pressure to break the seal. With the V facing down, pressure seals them in instead.
I shamefully admit that I could not get my old gaskets out...