So, had the dreaded "click, click" over the weekend and had to have a tow home. It's been a long time since she's stranded me and this time I'm stumped. While I was waiting for the tow truck, I ordered new starter contacts as I was certain this was the issue. Got them installed last night, but still only a "click, click" when I try to turn it over.
So, the troubleshooting begins. While I was working on getting the starter contacts changed out, I had the starter battery on a charger to rule out a bad battery. The charger tells me that the battery is good. I took the starter back out and did some testing with the battery:
1. Connected the positive of the battery to the starter motor terminal (not the normal post, but the one that comes out on the opposite side and would essentially bypass the contacts I just replaced). When I grounded the outside of the starter case, the motor spins.
2. Connected the positive side of the battery to the normal terminal. I grounded the outside of the case and then manually pushed the plunger down. The starter motor spins just fine in this case.
3. Connected a small wire to the plug on the solenoid that triggers the plunger to make contact. When I ground the outside of the case, the plunger gets pulled in to make contact with the starter contacts.
4. I hooked the battery back up and checked with a test light that I was getting power. Also showed 12+ volts with the multimeter.
5. Finally, I checked several spots around the starter to make sure I had a good ground. Also checked my engine ground under the oil filter and that looked good as well.
I was thinking after installing the new contacts and still get the "click, click" that maybe the starter motor had gone bad, but it seems the bench testing confirms that it's still spinning. When I try to turn it over when it's installed though, I don't hear it spinning at all.
I'm kind of stumped on this one.