There are two different spec bolts used on the LBJs, depending on year.
They have very different torque ratings, you may have bumped into that.
Hard to tell, since you don't list your vehicle in your sig.
Here's
Tim's write-up.
Basically:
Here's the part numbers for the two different style bolts
1996-2000 use a flanged bolt, part #90080-10066
2001-2002 use a bolt with a washer (it's a little longer than the 1996-2000 bolts), part #90119-10933.
The #90080-10066 bolts are suppose to be torqued to 59 ft-lbf
The #90119-10933 bolts have a lower tensile strength and should only be torqued to 37 ft-lbf.