Water under the bridge, so this is purely a data point for this thread should others come across it.
I've always avoided Amazon etc, and the whole "the cheapest price is the only thing that matters" mentality?
Everything I've ordered from McGeorge (Now Ourisman Toyota) has been fairly priced, 100% legit, shipped fast, and hassle free. That's worth more than saving $13, IMHO.
In fact, the last was my OEM, LBJ's, and they were precisely what I wanted and needed them to be.
Account | Ourisman Toyota of Richmond Online Parts