Hey, thanks guys. It was a bit of a rushed week as I was trying to prep for a trip Friday, but I missed my chance because I ended up confusing myself.
I opted to go with a set of Cooper Discoverer ATP 275/65 R18's. I'll save the 17" swap for down the road.
I did end up buying a set of the 2011 Tacoma rims (as I was undecided at that point) - those are the 17 x 7.5JJ ET30's - compared with my stock 18" Limited rims which are 18 x 7.5J ET25's. I used the rimsntires.com calculator and I think I just misread things. (Prior to seeing the posts above). The side by side comparison showed the INCREASED backspacing (further away from suspension), but the notes below said that package 2 would be closer to suspension components...
. Up against a time constraint, I decided to stick to the 18's
Anyway, I now have a full set of 5, 18" Limited rims with new Coopers! I can stick with them or sell them as a set if I choose. Interesting, but I think it would look a bit better with spacers. I thought I detected a slight rub when cranked all the way left (not right).
Thanks for the help