Update on the situation:
Could not wait until Thursday for the shop to call me. I work at a dealer and I had my front end guy do an alignment and balance all 4 tires again. He said alignment was slightly out but not too bad.
When he balanced the tires 1 tire was missing 50g, another 100g and another 165g. Drove the 4runner home yesterday and its riding the same (pulling to the right) but now is vibrating even more. He's going to check road force today, and possibly swap the tires to see if its a tire pull.
Attached is the alignment sheet from yesterdays alignment.
Hopefully this gets sort out soon