Subaru Crosstrek or Porsche Cayenne? - Toyota 4Runner Forum

jaggirl71 · 05-09-2024, 11:03 AM

Hello fellow 4Runner lovers,

Since my manual 99 4Runner just turned over 300k, it's time to add another capable manual SUV to the stable. Trying to nail down a decision between a manual Porsche Cayenne or a Subaru Crosstrek.

This is where I see the differences now:

Crosstrek: can get a more recent model year with low mileage, low-powered, good predicted reliability for a '22-23.

Cayenne: powerful engine, but high cost of maintenance, and 10-11 years old.

Anyone here own a manual version of these two models that can share their experiences with me? What do you love and hate?

MANUALS ONLY!

Thanks!

hoppyjr · 05-09-2024, 11:26 AM

Next post:

Sydney Sweeney or My Neighbors Grandmother

🥸

Seriously though, I’d prefer a new/newer Crosstrek as a daily driver.

Hampt · 12-06-2024, 05:42 AM

High cost of maintenance doesn't begin to describe it.

Unless you consider $5000+ transmission rebuild routine maintenance.

If you're going to own a Cayenne between 80k and l30k, transmission rebuild IS not uncommon.

NOT including a clutch job.

Or how about $3000 for new brake pads and rotors?

Does your Cayenne have air shocks? Put $3000 to $5000 aside now to get ready for they go bad.

You've been warned.

Site Navigation