not to speak for him, but I know my personal preference was for the 06+, I like the round fogs, and slight differences. I'm sure it's also for mileage and age.
Well, my '03 Limited has 235hp. Wish i had 270hp with VVT-i and other cosmetic stuff. But there's something i don't like on the '06-'09.
I'm with you, I dont like the minor body modifications they did. I also dont like the Grille, but to each his own. I realize a lot of people like the 05+'s better.