Well, I think I got my answer. Here is what the NAPA website
shows for calipers on the 16" wheel and 17" wheel, respectively:
As we can see, the little legs for mounting the caliper on are
somewhat longer on the 17"-wheel caliper.
I ordered the 17"-wheel calipers and rotors. I'll post pics and
let everyone know how it turns out. BTW, I measured the
stock rotor, and despite having 17"wheels from the factory,
my rotors are the smaller ones.
Now, what's NAPA going to say about the core charge... ;)