Sounds like so much fun! My wife and I are trying to make our way back there. Such a beautiful place (we were married in Hana) and so many awesome Toyotas.
That sounds a little high to me too. I just bought an 07 Limited for $24K in ATL and it had 51K miles. Loaded and clean, I think $24K is too much for an 05.
Plus you will always pay more going with a private seller.
I'm new here and from Atlanta. Just traded in my 98 Limited for an 07. Absolutely love it but feel like a va jay jay for not getting a 4x4. Too hard to find in the south.