Semantics of Torque Distribution
Hello all. I’m hoping you can help me with a semantic issue. It involves off-road driving and the distribution of torque.
Question 1: Imagine you have a vehicle with 3 locking differentials. And all three are locked. And the surface that you are driving upon, at the current moment, provides traction to only one wheel. All three diffs are locked and there is no wheel spin. Do we say that 100% of the torque output is going to the one wheel with traction? If not 100% then how much? (Let us discount mechanical losses and other inefficiencies.) Question 2: Now imagine the same question - all three differentials locked – but now two wheels have traction. Does each wheel receive 50% of the torque? Or do both wheels still get !00% of the torque, or is the torque split based on the weight distribution of the vehicle across both wheels, or what? This is relevant in terms of evaluating how much stress is being put on various components, so damage can be avoided. Let’s leave it at those two questions for now. I have others, but depending on how these two get answered the others might answer themselves. |
I know locked center full time 4wd/4H part time 4wd is 50/50 but I'm not sure if it's 50/50 again at the diff meaning 25% to each corner.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Your scenario is faulty. You can't really have only one wheel with all the traction (the vehicle can't "stand" on one wheel like a unicycle). Gravity will pull it down one way or another until at least two wheels are on the ground. Granted, each of those two wheels may have different amounts of traction (one on hard surface, the other in mud), but each of those two wheels will give some force to move the vehicle proportional to the amount of traction each has. A better way to look at this is to keep in mind that with all differentials locked, all wheels are forced to turn at the same rate, period. Those that have some contact with the ground, will propel the vehicle in proportion to the amount of traction they have. Those wheels that don't touch the ground will simply spin in the air at the same rate as all the other wheels -- the differentials are locked. Question 2: Same rules apply -- all wheels are forced to turn at the same rate. Those that touch the ground will provide some force to move the car; the ones in the air contribute nothing to moving the car, even though they are spinning at the same rate as the others. |
Torque is a force. You cannot apply torque to a wheel unless there is a resisting force (traction due the the wheel touching the ground). This physics rule applies here: for every action (force/torque) there is an equal and opposite reaction. If a tire is in the air, there is zero torque going to it even if it is spinning madly.
Another way to look at it is from a "work" prospective. Work is done if energy is transferred from one thing to another -- in a car case, energy from the engine is used to move the car. |
Quote:
But the same rule applies: with all differentials locked, all wheels are forced to turn at the same rate. The wheel that touches the ground will provide some force to move the vehicle. The others will just spin in the air and provide no motive force. |
Quote:
The SR5 4Runner does not have locking differentials from the factory, but it does have a transfer case that locks the front axle to the rear axle, forcing the two axles to turn at the same rate. Suppose that you come to two pot holes that leave diagonal wheels off the ground, one front wheel and the diagonal opposite rear wheel. If the car is fairly balance, it can rock back and forth supported only by those two wheels. I call that the "teeter-totter" mode. Since the axles are forced to turn at the same rate, the wheels over the holes will spin and no force is transferred to the wheels touching the ground; the vehicle doesn't move. Two ways to get out of that predicament: 1. Have the passengers move around until a third wheel touches the ground. Really hard to do and scary as hell if the holes are really deep, necessitating rocking at a sharp angle to one side. 2. Fortunately, the SR5 has a nifty "Atrac" button that engages the traction control system. In Atrac mode, the spinning wheels will be braked, allowing some energy to go to the wheels touching the ground. Attention Required! | Cloudflare This actually happened to me on Imogene Pass is western Colorado. We sat there for several seconds, not knowing what to do, wheels spinning in the air. Fortunately, before I realized I could use Atrac, the car very slowly tilted to one side until a third wheel touched the ground, then off we went. |
Quote:
Fully locked (Front, "center", and rear) - every wheel gets 25% of the torque regardless of what is on and off the ground. Open - the wheel that requires the least amount of torque to spin will dictate the amount of torque being applied to all other wheels. It takes say 20lb/ft of torque to move a wheel in the air so in that case, if you are completely open, you would only be getting that 20lb at the others (regardless of what your engine makes) and it isn't enough to actually move you. ATRAC just uses the brakes to increase resistance on that wheel that is spinning so more torque can then be applied to the wheels on the ground. |
Quote:
As an aside, I read that when the Limited’s center diff is unlocked the torque split front to rear is 60/40. I couldn’t understand how it could be that the front and rear prop shafts could turn at the same speed but deliver different torque. After a lot of research I learned that the reason has to do with the gear ratios in the planetary gear set in the center differential. When the center differential is locked, then the torque split is 50-50 front/rear. Quote:
The motor is supposedly putting out 275 ft-lbs of torque. In the scenario I outlined I think the single wheel with traction is getting most of that torque, and not ½ or ¼. No? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Many full time AWD cars are noted for having Torsen center differentials, including Subaru, Audi, and my VW Passat 4Motion (AWD). |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Transferring the torque to where traction is, is the concept of how a-trac works by applying opposing forces to the free spinning wheel(in the form of braking) to transfer power to where traction is. |
Quote:
Toyota: 4Runner (All 4WD 4Runner from 2003-2009) and 4Runner Limited (2010 to present), FJ Cruiser 6-speed manual, Toyota Landcruiser 200, Toyota Landcruiser 120/150, Toyota Fortuner, Toyota Land Cruiser Prado, Toyota Sequoia, Toyota Celica GT-Four/All-trac ST165, ST185, ST205, Toyota Caldina GTT and GT-Four |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:17 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by
DragonByte SEO (Pro) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by
Advanced User Tagging (Lite) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
***This site is an unofficial Toyota site, and is not officially endorsed, supported, authorized by or affiliated with Toyota. All company, product, or service names references in this web site are used for identification purposes only and may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Toyota name, marks, designs and logos, as well as Toyota model names, are registered trademarks of Toyota Motor Corporation***Ad Management plugin by RedTyger