Totality of the circumstances.
Look up the "greater danger theory."
Ya I said probably...meaning in most cases, yes.
"Bag of donuts??" For real....?
The cops I know that pulled the trigger and killed suspects, justifiably, are screwed up. One had to retire for PTSD anther got so skinny because everytime he ate he threw up.
It is not like the movies. These guys carry a burden with them, that I would not wish on my enemies.
Are there bad cops, judges, suspects, bankers, waiters,etc YES....you get the point there are bad eggs in every batch.
From what I've seen this is definitely true in some cases.
My best friend from childhood until the day he died peacefully and unexpectedly in his sleep, (no cause of death was found, other than his heart simply stopped) was a Cop. Back in 1994, he shot and killed a man. He was initially crucified in the biased media, and by some agenda-driven and biased organizations.
A thorough investigation by Police and Private Citizen review boards showed he had in fact shown great restraint, and would have been justified in shooting, long before he actually did.
The fact that he was called to the scene because this guy was there actively assaulting one of his baby mommas, was apparently missed by the media in their rush to judgement.
He was vindicated by the evidence in the initial investigation, and in the perhaps unfortunately inevitable ensuing Civil Trial brought by the woman who my best friends' actions' saved. I guess some low-life lawyer convinced her she could possibly win big bucks by suing the PD and Officer that saved her life. But I digress.
The effect of that shooting had a profound negative effect on my best friend. He couldn't get over the idea that he had killed some child's Dad, no matter how justified. Because being a good Father to his own Son, was the most important thing in his life.
Pointing out that while the guy he justifiably killed was indeed a sperm donor, he was in no way a figure in his offspring's life. Ie: he would get women pregnant, and then go on his way taking no responsibility whatsoever for the children he helped create.
I know of one other Officer that was more of an acquaintance, that had a tough time dealing with a justified shooting as well. He gained serious weight, went on desk duty, and retired from the job as soon as he was eligible to do so with full retirement benefits.