I did the same thing. It worked out well.
I went with Falken AT3/Ws in stock size two weeks ago. The only down side is a 1-2 MPG drop in fuel economy due to tread pattern and weight. Other than that, the Falken's are a fantastic tire!
Thanks for the tip about the Discount Tire thing. I actually went there after reading about it on another thread and got a quote for the Falken's and a trade-in offer. They offered me $200 for the four of them. Figured I could get more selling them myself.