After reading the helpful replies to my original post and further research on the web, I decided to go with the Canvasback Cargo Liners.
Here are some pictures (before, after, and after with the 2nd row seats back up). With the flash and shadows, the third picture shows the crease quite prominently but they actually look better/ok under natural light (see picture 2). At this point I would say I am 9/10 satisfied with the product. Will see if it holds up well and is easy to clean/maintain.
Looks awesome. I wish the made one that also covers the side panels. I feel they would get damaged more than carpet.