V8Man
Member
On quality electrical motors the commutors bars are usually a solid piece so they can wear and still function for a long life, unless one of the bars has come loose, disconnected from the armature wiring, or shorted out with the bar/s next to it, they should work as designed, if the commutor doesn't have excessive wear it can also be turn on a lathe/mill to even it out/true it up.
The brushes could be binding in their holders/guides from the wear debris buildup within the motor housing, which a good cleaning and light sanding would solve.
The only other problems stopping the motor from working would be wiring shorting out in the windings and or bad bushings/bearings.
This worked for me. Turn the com in a lathe. I had two burnt areas the op looks to have three. A drill and Emory cloth works too. In the long ago poor times "rebuilt" lots of starters this way.