Do you expect an A/T tire, or anything except a dedicated snow tire w/ studs, to be impressive on ice?
For most of us, it's more practical to run A/T or All season tires for maximum DD performance. In my area, we may only get icy slick roads once or twice a year, that's just not practical to run winter tires / studded tires for such a small usage period.
AT3's will be my next tires and have heard they do wonderful in winter weather.
What did I say that made you think I was insinuating tires be impressive on ice. No tire is impressive on ice except a studded tire. I was saying that for him both vehicles with the AT3s were terrible on ice. . . . much worse than you would expect, like running slicks. My tires do very well on ice if you drive carefully like you should and they are AT tires. This is just what he said and I have not personally tried them. I have a coupke more years before I will need tires and the Coopers will be on my short list, but I will do more research and listening to owners reviews before committing.