Alright, just my last .02 on Vw then I'm done. These cars get a bad wrap when people fail to maintain them at regular intervals then complain when they face expensive repairs. When these autos are serviced properly like all cars should be, they are very, very reliable. This whole debate though is simply the op's preference. If you want T4r reliability and you like the way Toyota's feel, then staying in the family with an Is300 is a good recommendation.