IMHO all of your choices are good. A pair of new CT's is the least fun choice but perhaps the best based on what you've described.
If you do go for 4 put the Mich LTX M/S2 on your list.
Are you running 17's or 18's? If it's 17's and you choose to go with 4 tires consider 265/70's vs 265/65's. They are a tiny bit taller. Many members use this size on non-lifted T4R's with no issues and you have many more options for less money.