4 cyl vs. 6 cyl

rustyrazor

New member
I don't think that anyone has a thread where the 22re fans have gone head to head with the V6 lovers.

So I thought it would be interesting to see what people have to say.

I've heard that the 22re can go forever and are more reliable so that's what I bought.

I don't think that either of the engines would be considered power houses. I also don't think my engine would be much better on gas than the 3 point slow V6.

So lets hear the pros and cons.
 
Register to hide this ad
Well, my opinion is that the 22re is definitely a better engine than the 3.0, but it is not without its problems...

Just be sure to keep your eye on the driver's side plastic timing guide. If it breaks on you, or if you start hearing excess chain slap when you crank it up in the mornings do a timing kit install ASAP.

And do yourself a favor and get a timing rail set that has at the very least a steel backed drivers side rail or both steel backed rails.

www.engnbldr.com has a good set that has just the driver's side backed with steel, and I think DOA racing and LC Engineering have set's for about 4 times the engnbldr set that have both rails in steel.

Not to mention that the timing job runs 11-14 hours depending on which shop you take it to just for labor. I got quotes from $800-$1200 just labor to do the job.

I have heard stories about the 3.0 head gasket jobs running well over $2k though so I suppose it could be worse...



I keep hearing that the 22re is so rock solid and lasts forever, but my 95 truck is on its 3rd such motor in 205k... I am not a big fan of the 22re either at this point.

Come next year if I keep the truck, it will get a small block chevy dropped in it. That will solve all of its problems.

But hey, other than that it is a good little motor. I guess. :jump:
 
I have a '90 p/u that I've owned since '95. I bought the 22re with 150K and that engine delivered pizzas til 315K when I lost a cylinder. I believe running 33's for 5 years with no gear change or mods probably helped send the engine to it's grave.

At 315K I replaced it with a remanned 22re and added a lot of engine mods as well as proper gear ratio for 37's. My truck will now cruise easily at 70 mph and doesn't have a problem getting there. Mileage is around 19 mpg city/highway combined. I now have 360K on my truck.

I also have a 3.4 with 56K running 33's and no engine mods. I have to say it's still running great even with the larger tires. Gas mileage is near the same on the 22re.
 
ovrrdrive said:
>8 snip 8<
I keep hearing that the 22re is so rock solid and lasts forever, but my 95 truck is on its 3rd such motor in 205k... I am not a big fan of the 22re either at this point.

Come next year if I keep the truck, it will get a small block chevy dropped in it. That will solve all of its problems.

But hey, other than that it is a good little motor. I guess. :jump:

So, how well have you maintained your 22RE's??? Who rebuilt the 2nd & 3rd engines? Did you run them (close) to the redline frequently?

You must be a glutton for punishment if you're going to put a chevy in. You'll be repairing that constantly!!!:bonk:

Mine had 3 miles on it when we took it for a test drive 20 years ago. Since then we've put 255k miles on it. It was running fine at 180k when I put a synthetic blend oil in it. Big mistake. My main bearing seals started leaking, so I had it rebuilt at 212k, with a slight bore and a TRD level 1 cam put in it. It has run great since. I change the oil at about 4000 mi on average (std dev of 500). Coolant every other year.

Mine gets around 20 mpg mixed most of the time. If I'm light-footed it will easily get 22. Straight highway: 24mpg. If I'm pulling the 2000+lb camper up 3000 ft in 80 miles to Vedauwoo, then I get about 16mpg.

I regularly pass 3.slow runners going up I-70 to the Eisenhower Tunnel (6000 ft to ~11,000ft elevation).

The guy that rebuilt my engine (Choice City Auto Repair, Ft. Collins, CO) is a Toyota Master Mechanic, who used to be the lead mechanic @ the local Toy dealership. He'd take a 22RE over a V6 any day.

So there's one data point for you.
 
Last edited:
I think maintenance is key for a long lasting 22RE. Sorry if I get off subject here, but is that TRD cam you have installed advertised as a 22R cam? I have a NWOR camshaft right now that has flat spots after 2 years and I want to get the TRD for my 22RE for the warranty. Problem is, I can't get a for sure answer if the 22R cam is the same for the 22RE.

Thanks!
 
Ill4Runner said:
I think maintenance is key for a long lasting 22RE. Sorry if I get off subject here, but is that TRD cam you have installed advertised as a 22R cam? I have a NWOR camshaft right now that has flat spots after 2 years and I want to get the TRD for my 22RE for the warranty. Problem is, I can't get a for sure answer if the 22R cam is the same for the 22RE.

Thanks!

Mine's been running great since March '03.

There's a pretty good page at:
http://mywebpages.comcast.net/jonmarkstewart/cam.htm

HTH
 
86Original said:
So, how well have you maintained your 22RE's??? Who rebuilt the 2nd & 3rd engines? Did you run them (close) to the redline frequently?

You must be a glutton for punishment if you're going to put a chevy in. You'll be repairing that constantly!!!:bonk:

Mine had 3 miles on it when we took it for a test drive 20 years ago. Since then we've put 255k miles on it. It was running fine at 180k when I put a synthetic blend oil in it. Big mistake. My main bearing seals started leaking, so I had it rebuilt at 212k, with a slight bore and a TRD level 1 cam put in it. It has run great since. I change the oil at about 4000 mi on average (std dev of 500). Coolant every other year.

Mine gets around 20 mpg mixed most of the time. If I'm light-footed it will easily get 22. Straight highway: 24mpg. If I'm pulling the 2000+lb camper up 3000 ft in 80 miles to Vedauwoo, then I get about 16mpg.

I regularly pass 3.slow runners going up I-70 to the Eisenhower Tunnel (6000 ft to ~11,000ft elevation).

The guy that rebuilt my engine (Choice City Auto Repair, Ft. Collins, CO) is a Toyota Master Mechanic, who used to be the lead mechanic @ the local Toy dealership. He'd take a 22RE over a V6 any day.

So there's one data point for you.

Well, I can see you're fishing but you're going to go home with an empty cooler I'm afraid. :bash:

I wouldn't say I have been on the same level as if I took it to the dealer every 3k and handed them a credit card, but I have done pretty good with it.

The most any of my motors have ever gone without an oil change is about 5k, but is usually closer to 3k. I was probably a little more relaxed with the original motor than I have been with the successive motors, but I wouldn't say at all that it was neglected.

I have never redlined the motor and rarely ever take it offroad. As a matter of fact, I haven't offroaded it for at least the last 3 years at all.

I was pulling a 2500lb boat with it that I think killed the first motor, and probably hurt the second before we got our first V6 4runner that took over towing duties.

The second motor came from a junkyard and supposedly had 80k on it. It lasted about 60k longer then pooped. In all fairness it was probabyl just a blown head gasket but at the time I was kind of pissed that it went out again and decided to get a remanned engine from a local engine shop. The second engine never went more than 4000 miles without a change. I do them at every 3300, 6600, and 9900 on the odometer religiously. That way I never have to write down milage or wonder if its due.

The third motor recently had 12k on it when the plastic drivers side rail broke off, went through the bottom gear, jumped the time and bent all 4 intake valves in the head. Too bad it took me 2 years to get 12k on it, because the warranty was gone when it happened. I did the repair work myself this time and I think it is done right and will hopefully last me a bit this time.

I did go with a rebuilt head from J and C Enterprises that has a Crane cams Stage 2 cam, O/S SS engnbldr vales, and heavier valve springs in it. I also used an engnbldr steel backed drivers side rail timing kit too. As long as the bottom end lasts it should be ok this time but I am convinced that once you blow the stock motor you cannot get a quality replacement for it. The rebuilt motors just aren't as high quality unless they are rebuilt with all new OEM parts which would probably cost $4k.

Now that I have been all through this motor and learned a lot more about it, I feel much more confident with most of the things that could go wrong with it. But I'm still dropping a Chevy Crate motor in it next year.

These motors are all completely brand new long block kits and the one I'm looking at puts out 290hp/320lbs and in Chevy applications they warranty it for 3 years with 100k milage. I'm sure putting it in a yota will void that, but if they are confident enough to warranty it like that it must be built pretty good.

And compared to replacement rebuilt 22re's that go for $1600-1800 around here, brand new in a crate from Chevy including heads only runs $1600 for one like I'm looking at. Not to mention in a pinch you can get them from people locally for $250 and a case of beer if you need to, its not hard to see why even if for replacement reaons only I'm considering the SBC swap.

I'm tired of inferior engines... I'm tired of over-priced replacement parts... And most of all I'm tired of a slow truck.

The swap will fix all of that in a nice, neat box.

If you're curious about the engine I'm talking about, here's the link:

http://www.crateenginedepot.com/197...M1-New-Goodwrench-Engine-10067353--P62C0.aspx


I'm not just talking out of my ass here... I've been considering it for quite some time.
 
Overdrive, Sounds like you know your engine now. Yes, I paid about $3500 to have mine rebuilt with factory parts. It does seem like you got an inferior rebuilt. In addition, your engine probably had to work harder on a daily basis than mine does. I believe the 95s are a bit heavier than my 86 (3600lbs curb).

BTW, I doubt that there have been 8 times in 20 years that someone else has changed the oil in mine. I virtually always do it myself. Gives me a chance to get a good look at what is happening underneath. ;)

What kind of gas mileage do you expect from your chevy swap?
 
Last edited:
86Original said:


What kind of gas mileage do you expect from your chevy swap?

Honestly?

About 8-10 mpg is all I think I'll get.

But I usually only drive this truck to work and back. We take the '03 runner on the weekends wherever we go.

Really its the 4runner that has spoiled me. I want a V8 and auto badly now after driving it. It really makes driving fun again.

As for weight, my xcab 95 scales out around 4500lbs. Yep, it's a big dog.

Don't get me wrong though, I love my truck. If I didn't I wouldn't even consider the swap I'd just get rid of it and get something else. I'm just afraid that if I get another used truck I won't like it as well and end up with junk. I don't want another big payment either, so fixing up the truck seems like the way to go for me.

And after all, I did buy it new and gave them about $26k of my hard earned cash for it after financing. I feel like I almost can't get rid of it now. :lol:

I am still on the fence though... I may just find an '02 xcab 4x4 V6 with my name on it by next year and sell this truck to pay for rims, tires and lift...

I still have about 6 months to decide though... ;):


(holy crap I'm long winded... :bigok: )
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,309
Messages
3,554,075
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top