Welp...just as I thought, the insurance company totaled it and are now trying to pull a fast one on me. They offered me $8818 flat out, or $6300 if I kept it. That doesn't include my $500 deductible. I just sent in a nicely worded eff you letter regarding their offer. I told them what the NADA and KBB value was as well as sent them some examples of the exact same truck within a 100 mile radius. That price is a couple thousand off several other identical trucks in the area. KBB private party value is Very Good condition is $10,185...the Good Condition is $9885. NADA Clean Retail in $11,000. I was told they pull their values from JD Power & Associates...go figure. Waiting to see what they say in regards to my email.