Cooper ST Maxx vs Goodyear Duratrac/Kelly Safari TSR

[Nashvillerunner]

I know there have been tons of "tire" posts started but I need you guys opinion on these tires.

I am currently running the Nitto Terra Grappler in 265/70/17 and have around 80,000 miles on them and it is time for some new tires. I mostly do on road but do run off road occasionally. I love the Nitto's but I want something a little more aggressive.

I have narrowed my choices down to the Cooper ST Maxx and the GY Duratrac/Kelly Safari TSR. I have read plenty of reviews of all of these tires.
The Cooper ST Maxx is great and low noise on road, great in the rain, mud, snow but heavy and will hit my MPG a little more and a little more expensive.
The GY Duratrac/Kelly Safari TSR is a little more aggressive than the Nitto's and the only bad reviews I have seen is about the sidewalls of the Duratracs.

If you had to choose would go with the new Cooper ST Maxx's, Goodyear Duratrac or the Kelly Safari TSR?

I am just wanting opinions and weigh my options on what I choose. I would appreciate any help, personal reviews or comments you guys can give.

 

[Marc P]

I ran the TSR's for 30k on my 3rd gen...one of the best tires I have had. Quiet, great offroad, and did not wear badly...plus I got them cheap.

 

[Nashvillerunner]

I ran the TSR's for 30k on my 3rd gen...one of the best tires I have had. Quiet, great offroad, and did not wear badly...plus I got them cheap.

Thanks Marc that just made my decision for me. I will be getting those.