crossroads... decisions... need help

SnowLizard

New member
Well, I'm torn... And here is why.

We love camping, but my wife is, to put nicely, fragile. She has bone pain, ciliac disease, and the foods she can eat, can literally be written on a post-it note, so not much variation, nutrition or energy. All this boils down to her quality of life. She loves camping. But can't drive due to vision issues, she is keeping everyone else safe by refusing to drive (that's a good thing)

Camp setup was too much for me solo, and her recovery from riding all day didn't give her rest she needs... So, we bought a custom toy hauler, the front has a counter and kitchenette, and the sides fold down the queen size beds. It's great, comfy and wife relaxes faster, and can actually recover while camping. we are still 'roughing it, as trailer doesn't have toilet/bath. It's awesome and efficient and she can rest so much sooner. it's really a cabin on wheels. Best family investment and we are camping more, we have plans for an propane inverter generator for more winter camping (heater).

The 99 4runner is too small the pull the 20ft (with tongue), 3000lbs double axle hauler, loaded it can weight max 7000 lbs. So, we bought a 2004 Sr5 4wd Sequoia, to tow the trailer, it's great, we love it. It's comfy, even better for the wife. Her down time is usually over night after a good days travel. With the trailer, setup is now 20min... vs maybe an hour plus+++... sure we can't get into the 'bush' as before, but it works and it's a small trade off. Sequoia has the 240hp 315tq 4.7L non-vvti 4spd auto

Okay, now the other part... I want to offload and explore the areas we stop/camp at, but the dilemma is I'm with the sequoia while camping, I have a ToyHauler... and no 4runner with me.

I have two options, a toy or offroad the sequoia...
If I lift and mod the sequoia I know it will perform, sure, it won't fit in the tight trails, but at least I won't get into any real trouble spots... A toy on the other hand keeps the sequoia stock (ish, more on that later). But it saves it from trail dmg, and keeps the tow vehicle safe. it won't ruin the vacation if the toy breaks, vs breaking the sequoia. then the other issue, modify the sequoia and the 'crap range' just gets worse... I'm lucky now to get 180 miles while towing @ 24 gal fill up (26 gal tank) yeah running empty, scary!

A toy is expensive, I'll be frank, living in AZ, I want AC, it's a must. But cost is stupid... 20k!!!!??? It will be a while for used ones to come down in price. so i have time to save and get the cars in order. it's not going to happen over night.

The 4 runner is too big to fit the trailer, 13ft 8in cabin for a 15ft 4runner, camping is too far to run home and swap vehicles, wife can't drive. Kid is only 5... So another 11yrs??

I want to modify the 04 Sequoia but not ruin it's towing and MPG, I'm disappointed in towing power, mostly the gear searching I just want it to hold gear longer, sure re-gearing 'could help' but be honest it's low on power to maintain it's speed period, been researching, and bought a supercharger, after buying it we realized its a gamble. I was hoping with the super, the truck can run more efficiently at the same speeds, not go faster, but hold the taller gear longer and actually use 4th gear towing on flat ground... Hopefully/ maybe increase range... Price for fill up will be more I'm aware of that.
Maybe rear springs I'm looking for 1.75 in lift so it won't squat towing. Other than those, keep it stock. AFTER power is settled with the super, I'll revisit with the possibility of re-gearing to 4.86's or 5.12's depending. I'm running stock tires, 265/65r17. With Super I'm looking at 350hp 360tq

I love the 4runner, it does so much, but I can't justify it with a toy, I'd rather get a simple gas sipper for work if I did the toy...

Recently, we rented a polaris ranger northstar 2017 for a weekend, went camping and wow, the family had fun, exploring and enjoying ourselves... I can really see it part of our activities, the polaris wasn't modified, and I ran 15 psi in tires, helped ride real smooth. Wife enjoyed it, but she still wasn't sold on the price (neither am I)... Probably won't rent again... but it was sure fun. will it be a polaris, IDK, it will be 4wd w/ lockers, enclosed, AC and Heat. in the end I don't care which brand.

Now comes my dilemma... Lately I've taken the 4runner farther and harder because the polaris could... I got within 1inch from belly of truck, stacked rocks, ect... I still LOVE this 4runner, it's amazing. It's so capable... sure I'm not armored, I only have a rear bumper, 1.5 inch lift and running 32's... add all that and I'll scrape the belly next time I'm there. so it has some room to improve. I've taken it personally for overnight camping, or fire burning, and just sleep in the back, I'm not doing trails at night and I know the sequoia can fill this job when i'm not exploring.

I'm saddened and honestly thinking of selling it... we did have a great time and the 'toy' did fit the family. maybe it was the 'honeymoon' feeling of the family. IDK. but my daughter actually wants to do it again and keeps asking if we can. (it's probably gonna make me cave and do it again... I only get so much time while she's this age...)

weight... the 04 sequoia 4wd can tow 6200 lbs... dry weight is 3k, crew cab polaris is 2400lbs, single cab (3 seats) is 1900lbs, we took the 3 seater... the crew cab leaves 800lbs for gear and food. I have air bags in sequoia rear springs to lift for better tow feeling (really makes a difference in handling). I do have load levelers and sway bars for trailer.

Newer Sequoia?? sell this one, with super not installed, but included, and buy a newer 08+ sequoia with the 5.7L. It'll have the same power that the 04 with super would have had (actually more) but its IFS and IRS, towing is only 7100 max, and it's bigger, MPG is the same as the 04... range is the same... tank is the same 26gal capacity... 5.7L is 381hp 401tq 5spd auto

so here comes the questions...

1) Will the super actually help the sequoia not 'gear search' as often, and maintain the speed?
2) If it can stay in taller gears longer will that take more gas, or be 'even'?
3) Would you run the sequoia for offroad and run the risk of breaking the towing vehicle?
4) Am I wrong to think the super will increase 'range'?
5) Am I looking at this realistically??
6) Is getting a toy and selling the 4runner a smart option?
7) Would you put in the super on the 04 sequoia or go with a newer sequoia with 5.7 engine?
8) Or just sell super, sell 4runner, get the toy and tow with the 04 sequoia as is?
 
Register to hide this ad
You have a lot on your plate.

I would look for either a Lexus 470, or by this time 460 if you still desire off-road capability. If not, then look at the 08 and later Sequoia. I am not sure they even offered 4wd.

My sister’s best friend from college has celiac, it has been a roller coaster. She couldn’t work for close to two years back in 03-04, but since has been almost living a normal life through some meds, probiotics, and exercise. Good luck with it.
 
It sounds like with a tow rig you won’t be using the 4runner either way since it’s too long to fit in the toy hauler. As for the Sequoia, current vs new dilemma, why not install the supercharger and give it a try first? You could always uninstall and sell separately if the resale doesn’t favor you leaving it on. If it does do the trick, you can put the extra money you’d spend on the newer Sequoia on a side by side to explore with. Still leaves your 4runner sidelined. Tough decisions either way.
 
It sounds like with a tow rig you won’t be using the 4runner either way since it’s too long to fit in the toy hauler.
Yeah, it sucks because of the investment... Nail on the head

As for the Sequoia, current vs new dilemma, why not install the supercharger and give it a try first? You could always uninstall and sell separately if the resale doesn’t favor you leaving it on.
We could, but then the cost of installation and removal... And the SC needs a rebuild. It's been off the and sitting in my garage for a year now.

If it does do the trick, you can put the extra money you’d spend on the newer Sequoia on a side by side to explore with. Still leaves your 4runner sidelined. Tough decisions either way.
Can the older sequoia safely tow the max weight? Can it go over that weight? Even with SC, is it still rated for the 6200lbs capacity as it's really determined by frame strength?

Is 800 lbs enough for week long food, water, clothes, toy fuel and other supplies, like generator and propane (2x40 lbs bottles) I think I'm over limit... I could stick to single cab 3 seater, and save an extra 500lbs
 
The part that I like the most is the ability to jump in and go in the 4runner, run down the freeway, hit the trail, and then run home with the 4runner... With a toy, I now have to bring the trailer, every time... Extra time for towing, and another tank to fill.. I really love the simplicity of the 4runner... Kid and wife with dogs fit fine, plenty of room.

But then limited to the areas nearby... Not many trees and no place to camp with dogs offleash (cactus crazy)

The sequoia can do that, and yes the newer ones can have 4wd too... They have the multi mode the 3rd and 4gen are known for... Tundras take them and bolt them on the them all the time...

We have driven 3x 05-07 with the 280hp vvti 4.7 and 5spd trans... Not much different from the butt-o-meter... Also, the super will not install on the vvti motor... I'll get more power with the 04 w/SC vs 05-07 vvti. Granted, that extra gear would have been nice.
 
These gear ratios look too close to make a difference in towing... Currently I'm 2nd and 3rd gear on the 04...

04 sequoia
Gear ratios ( :1)
1st 2.804
2nd 1.531
3rd 1.000
4th 0.705
Reverse 2.393
Differential Ratio 4.100


05 sequoia
First (:1):3.52
Second (:1):2.04
Third (:1):1.40
Fourth(:1):1.00
Fifth (:1):0.72
Reverse (:1):3.22
Final Drive Axle Ratio (:1):4.10

08 sequoia

Transmission and axle ratios (x:1)
I= 3.333,
II = 1.960,
III = 1.353,
IV = 1.000,
V = 0.728,
VI = 0.588,
R = 3.061,
Diff = 3.909,
Low = 2.618
 
Yeah, it sucks because of the investment... Nail on the head


We could, but then the cost of installation and removal... And the SC needs a rebuild. It's been off the and sitting in my garage for a year now.


Can the older sequoia safely tow the max weight? Can it go over that weight? Even with SC, is it still rated for the 6200lbs capacity as it's really determined by frame strength?

Is 800 lbs enough for week long food, water, clothes, toy fuel and other supplies, like generator and propane (2x40 lbs bottles) I think I'm over limit... I could stick to single cab 3 seater, and save an extra 500lbs

I was thinking the SC would help hold gears better, but you’re probably still limited to the max towing weight determined by the frame. I don’t think HP changes that. Rebuild and install cost changes the practicality of trying it first too.

The only other thing that comes to mind to keep the 4runner would be to downgrade the accommodations to a pop up camper. You can get them with some nice features and plenty of room for the 3 of you but they are a lot smaller and you’re definitely trading off the luxury of the toy hauler for the simplicity of the pop up camper. Some of them come with a cargo deck, which helps pack up more gear without overloading the 4Runner interior. I think it sounds like a good compromise but only you can determine if it fits your family’s needs.

jayco-baja.jpg
 
We did think of the pop up, but we can't take that to redwood or Yosemite... Basicly any bear country must have hard sides for trailer, with current toy hauler, sure it has side tent fold downs, but we can take the Matress and place on floor, and not use the tents during that area...

I told my wife we needed the smaller one http://www.intechrv.com (Discover Flyer Mini Camper) they no longer offer the one we bought... The discover.

We just finished paying off the discover... It's officially ours.
 
Either you like the trailer you have now too much to give up and then would at least require the current sequoia made off-road ready

or

are liking the current runner so much you want to keep it and must then get a smaller, lighter (3500lb empty weight) trailer-there are plenty available these days.

or

Next step up for me would be go with an 08+sequoia to get the 5.7(these are designed for 1.3M miles before a rebuild is necessary) with a timing chain vs. the timing belt of the 4.7. Luck and enjoy. :cowboy:
 
Does anyone know if adding a super charger increase range?

Or does it hurt range?

I'm not looking for faster, so if travel is 65-70mph and 8.5mpg.... Without super charger... Does super help go farther at same speeds?

Adding super is cheaper than switching to a newer 08+...

Sounds like it's the right way to think, that adding power doesn't mean that you an increase of tow capacity...
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,306
Messages
3,554,044
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top