I used the Herculiner, and I bought the gallon kit for $100 bucks or so at Auto Zone. I decided to do it because my friend had his jeep line-x'ed and I really liked it, however he paid $500 to have that done. I was wanting to get the weather tech mats but they would have been $400 bucks too. So I decided that I would give it a shot for $100 bucks and if it didn't work out I would put the carpet back in. Plus I wanted something that I could put muddy stuff in after hiking and hunting and just wash out, especially since there are 4 drain plugs in the back and one in each footwell. If you decide to do it just be aware that the pad they give you in the kit is not good at all for roughing up the surface, I actually just used sandpaper. It does smell when you first do it but it goes away after a week or so. Also, the Herculiner looks almost wet at first but after a while and after use can dull a bit, it is super gritty and grippy though. Overall, I really like it and I think it will hold up well for what I intend to use it for. I actually did the whole runner front to back and I can post pictures of the front once I get some better pictures, (by the time I got to that part it was dark out). I can post more pictures of the progress as well if anyone is interested in how to do it.