MT makes up for the horrible torque curve but in the end the 1GR-FE is a better truck engine even if it does make less HP the torque comes on way sooner.
I wouldn't really call 200 rpm "way sooner." I drove a Tacoma over two days last weekend and I can tell you in an instant that I'd rather have that power plant than ours.
Why? Mostly the 6AT. That simple upgrade makes a world of difference.
Posted elsewhere, but here are my thoughts on the 2GR-FKS/Tacoma:
For the most part, this powertrain feels 80% like the 1GR-FE with a few notable differences:
- It shifts much faster and much smoother - I'm not talking about more often because of the 6AT, but the actual shifting action is notably faster and smoother.
- The truck moves off the line better for sure. Those of you who are worried about this being a "high revving engine that has no torque" are wrong. The peak torque arriving 200RPM later isn't discernible in every day driving and the shorter gear ratios help significantly with stop and go driving.
- The 2GR-FKS is noticeably faster at the top end (AND NOT AT THE EXPENSE OF TORQUE ON THE LOW END). Accelerating on the highway is easier with the extra gear and different tuning. You no longer have to wait for your turn to pass - this engine will jump out there and snap through gears much faster.
Two negatives: The Tacoma has a lot less sound deadening than the 4R, so the entire experience is a little lower rent - more road noise for sure.
The Tacoma interior is pretty cheap and there's no way I'd go out of a 4R into a Tacoma just because the 4R feels like an overall vastly superior product with overall quality, fit and finish, interior appointments, etc.
Disclaimer: This Tacoma was ~300lbs lighter than my Limited 4x4 4R so the weight might have accounted for some of the brisker acceleration, but I don't think that's a significant number.
Summary: We'd be pretty lucky to have this motor in the 4Runner. It doesn't apply to me now because I'm keeping mine for a long time to come, but if Toyota does decide to drop this power plant into the 4R, I don't think any of us have anything to worry about. It would be a welcome upgrade for every day drivability. With that said, all new Toyotas are getting Dynamic Force engines so I have a feeling that a next generation 4Runner would get a completely different motor all together, and probably an 8AT at least.