And After:
I would not suggest these to anyone without grey cladding unless you have the silver rack on top and got them painted to match. The match to the cladding is really good, but not 100% in some light. Construction seems good, and not overpriced. So far the paint has held up well.
As far as mud in the door panels, I have not noticed a difference, but also have not been in a lot of mud. I doubt they would be as effective as the stock running boards.
FYI- I chose these because I am getting a lift and don't like the look of the stock boards on lifted Runners.