Goodyear Fortera TT vs. Michelin X-Radial LT-2?

Union Federal

New member
Let me start off by saying that I am a proud new owner of a 06 4runner Sport 4x4 in silver. I previously had an 07 Ford Escape XLT 4x4. I traded it in for the 4 runner and the 4runner is one sweet ride! I love this truck.

My question is that the truck has the original Dunlop Grandtreks in 265/65-17 with 31k on them and this seems to be the weak point on an otherwise spectacular ride. These tires are downright treacherous in the rain and I don't want to find out how bad they can be in the snow, which we get a fair amount of here. I am a Sam's Club member and they have these two different tires in stock that I can get (going with stock 265/65-17 because I can't afford to replace the spare). Both tires cost about the same and I should be out the door for under $900. The specs for the Michelin X-Radial LT-2 are exactly identical to the Michelin LTX MS-2.

My needs are: 99% on road use, but I occasionally go on the sugar sand trails and hard packed roads to go fishing (never had a problem on these roads with 4wd and highway tires).

2. I need a long wearing tire, as I cannot afford to replace tires every 35k. Looking for a 60-70k tire, so as much as I like the way the Revo's look, I don't think they'll fit my needs.

3. I'd like a quiet tire, but it would be nice if they at least looked somewhat aggressive. The raised white letters on the Grandtreks actually look real nice on the silver truck.

4. I live in a mountainous area with many steep hills and we get about 50" of snow a year. My job only closes in a severe weather state of emergency, so good snow handling is very important. I had permanent AWD on my Ford Escape with Conti Contitrac tires and they had some trouble in deep snow and offroad (switched to used Cooper tires, which went thru anything but were super noisy). I don't think any of the roads around here require a snowflake emblem to travel on them (is that only out west?)

Everyone seems to love Michelins and the treadwear of 720 means they should wear like iron, but they don't look too aggressive for snowtravel. On the other hand, the Goodyears look good, but unfortunately lack the outline white letter, and are rated for severe service so I imagine they'd be good in the snow.
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Welcome! There's a couple of good reviews of the TT in the Perf Zone section. There's not been much feedback on the Mich LTX MS-2 yet. Some have run the LTX A/T2 and seem to like them well enough. I would imagine the M/S2 would be even more civilized and a good tire.


I would also read about the GYear Silent Armour. Some here have them, like them, they have the 'snowflake', they have raised white letters, and most claim they're quiet and wear well.


It sounds like the Mich will be agood fit for you but the others are worth a look.

:cheers:
 
Welcome! There's a couple of good reviews of the TT in the Perf Zone section. There's not been much feedback on the Mich LTX MS-2 yet. Some have run the LTX A/T2 and seem to like them well enough. I would imagine the M/S2 would be even more civilized and a good tire.


I would also read about the GYear Silent Armour. Some here have them, like them, they have the 'snowflake', they have raised white letters, and most claim they're quiet and wear well.


It sounds like the Mich will be agood fit for you but the others are worth a look.

:cheers:

So if I was looking at all terrain tires, would you recommend Michelin LTX A/T2 or the Goodyear Silent Armors? Compared to the Dunlops, how quiet would these be? I do have to admit, the Dunlops are pretty quiet.
 
So if I was looking at all terrain tires, would you recommend Michelin LTX A/T2 or the Goodyear Silent Armors? Compared to the Dunlops, how quiet would these be? I do have to admit, the Dunlops are pretty quiet.


From what I've read both are pretty mild/quiet. I would think the Mich would be a touch quieter. IIRC someone claimed the GYSA's were quieter than the Dunlops he replaced so from a noise perspective I think you're good either way. If money isn't an object and you want long-life the Michelins seem tough to beat. I had a set of the old A/T series. I loved them and after 35k they still looked brand new.
:cheers:
 
these are the GY WRANGLER with silent armour, & they come with white letters, & are great in all weather, highway, & quiet to boot.
GYSA006.jpg~original
 
these are the GY WRANGLER with silent armour, & they come with white letters, & are great in all weather, highway, & quiet to boot.
GYSA006.jpg~original

They are really nice, aggressive looking tires. I've been pricing them and the best I have been able to find is $229 a piece, vs $185 a piece for the Forteras or the X Radials. Its quite a bit more than I can spend right now. I keep waiting for a sale though....
 
I just installed these a week ago and they are really nice. I like the aggressive tread pattern and they are quieter than the Revo's they replaced.
 
I just installed these a week ago and they are really nice. I like the aggressive tread pattern and they are quieter than the Revo's they replaced.

I finally made a decision and went with the older Revo's in 265/65-17, even though I initially didn't want such an aggressive tire. I picked them due to the price (buy 3 get 1 free) and they ended up being $120 cheaper then the TripleTreds or the Michelins.

The Michelins turned me off because they are so Mom-car looking, and the reviews I have read on the TripleTreds almost everyone said that they are really good until 30k and then they stink. They tried to hard sell me on the Revo 2's, but I have to say they cost a lot more and definitely do not look as aggressive. Nice enough tires though.

My initial impression of the Revos: they are noisier than the Dunlops, for sure, but they handle better. Good grip and they look aggressive with the white lettering out. Also seem to make the car look taller and fill the wheel wells better. No idea about wet weather yet, but from what I read they are phenominal in the snow. The dealer admitted that they wear out quick and I should only expect 40k or so from them.

Time to get tires on the wife's MDX now, won't be going with Revo's!! Maybe Long Trail T/A Touring.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,315
Messages
3,554,104
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top