TheBlueWave said:I respect the decision not to use a dipstick so people can't mess with the tranny as much and invite dirt and moisture, but for things like this its a real POA IMO.
TheBlueWave said:Your perspective makes perfect sense, but what about those who feel the need to check the fluid all the time? Auto transmissions don't need to be checked at every single stop for gas. If the dipstick is removed repeatedly, can't dirt and moisture make its way in when the dipstick is removed? Not saying it gets in there otherwise, but if it is out once per week moisture could invade the transmission, whereas engines can handle the moisture (PCV system) transmissions can't as well.
Oh well, mostly speculation on my part. I'm no mechanic, just an engineer who doesn't design or build cars but is trying to learn.:help:
TechWrench said:I would have to disagree with that one. Any well designed dipstick and tube should have a rubber seal at the top of the dipstick with a metal tube cover so dirt and moiiture shouldn't be a problem. IMHO, this is just another example of manufacturers 'dumbing' down their products to protect idiots against themselves. We have all heard the 'nightmare' idiot stories where someone puts brake fluid in the power steering pump, fills the engine with oil up to the fill cap, or puts engine oil in the trans filler tube. You can't protect those people from themselves! So they remove the easily used means of checking fluid condition, and level from those of us who actually know what we are doing to protect the few idiots from doing dumb things. Not to mention the additional cost now required to have an 'expert' in a dealer check it for you. This is, of course, assuming that 'expert' in the dealership who was washing cars last week, knows how to perform the procedure correctly. This whole trend toward 'lifetime' lubrication, and dealer only servicable components annoys the s#*t outa me.
RANT over........:soapbox:
bonedoctor said:Hey, are you talking about my friend waaay back in college? He was doing something under the hood, taking a really long time. Asked what he was doing when he came in and he said, "I was adding some oil, but the hole was really little and it took a long time". Puzzled, I asked again. He had been trying to put the oil in through the little hole in the end of the dipstick! Predictably, most ended up on the ground. This is also the same guy who painted his car with a brush. It was a POS, but come on! What a mow-ron!
TechWrench said:One of the 'bonehead' moves I mentioned above happened to a neighbor on my block years ago. He went out of town on a business trip, and left car with wife. Told her to check the oil regularly because of a valve cover leak he didn't have time to fix before he left. He showed her how to check oil, and told her he had a case of oil in the garage if it needed more. He forgot to show her how to add more oil.............
She comes walking down our block and asks me to check it for her, because , she had found it low, filled it up, and now couldn't start it. As you can probably guess, when I checked the dipstick, it was full to the top. When I asked her how much she put in, she showed me a pile of empty cans in the garage. She then showed me how she removed the oil fill cap on top of the engine, and filled it until it reached the brim...............Engine was hydro-locked and wouldn't turn. Had to drain about 22 quarts of oil from the engine and refill it to get it to run. She was pissed at her husband for not showing her how to fill it properly, and begged me to not tell him what she did.