They should. At least with people that know how to be responsible and mature about it. But I understand that's not the easiest to decipher who is what, especially these days.
But letting people know about a certain trail that can potentially put you on some fish (with some googling and exploring) shouldn't be taboo. I can understand not wanting to give up GPS coordinates...but I'm off on a tangent hahah
Everyone thinks their spot is "secret" like no one has ever fished there or doesn't know about it. People here think like that. We live on a damn island just because someone stopped and decided to fish doesn't mean they following you to your "secert" spot.