Should I get a 3rd gen t4r or a 1996 Yugon GT

RichInCanada

New member
So I'm finally getting my license back in 2 weeks after 7 years without one as the result of a major stroke.
I need the ride height of an SUV and 4wd for winters here.
I've decided on a 3rd gen 4runner, I like how they look but I also found down the street a beautiful, original,rust free not-beat-up 1996 Yukon GT 2-door. I am aware it has a higher towing capacity, but it doesn;t have a sunroof. They are hard to find in good condition, please give me some good reasons why the 4runner is a better choice (aside from being Japanese) or visa-versa.
 
Register to hide this ad
Glad to hear you are doing better and now have your license again!

I had three 2-door Tahoes and wished I kept them (or at least one of them...lol). Two were the Sport model and therefore much like the Yukon GT with the monochromatic theme. I loved those trucks!

I set mine up with small lifts and larger, better tires and they were unflappable when going off-road, and downright fun in town as they actually handled very well despite their size with great turning feel and provided spritely acceleration due to very good HP and low end torque. They also could tow and haul greater loads due to their larger size and power/torque curves.

The 4Runners give you 4 doors with the same overall length, but also provide less headroom, shoulder room, and legroom compared to the 2-door Tahoe/Yukon. For example, a 1997 2-door Tahoe/GT had a 111.5-inch wheelbase with an overall length of 188 inches and 77.1 inches in overall width while the 4th Gen 4Runner had a 109.8-inch wheelbase with an overall length of 190 inches and 73.8 inches in overall width. However, having a 4Runner with 4 doors is quite an advantage as ingress/egress to the rear seats in the Yukon/Tahoes can be a challenge for some (but quite comfortable with large viewing side windows once back there); the 2-door Yukon rear windows obviously do not roll down which is another advantage of the 4-door 4Runner.

I think it's a toss-up on durability as the Chevy/GM in those years held up pretty well, but they also typically got beat up pretty good too which is why if I ever find one in terrific shape I would pick it up. The power- and drivetrains last forever like the 4runners. But I still have to say that the Toyota interior quality was a step ahead over the Chevy even in those years. As far as sunroofs go, you can also add a high quality aftermarket one like I did on my 2004 Tahoe Z71 and 2004 Dodge 2500; the larger trucks have plenty of headroom and roof space as to not interfere with the roof integrity and never had an issue with flex or leaks whatsoever.

Of the 3rd or 4th Gen Toyotas, they are absolutely great vehicles and will last forever if taken care of. I really like the 4th Gen looks and features with slightly more room and power over the 3rd Gen. The Toyotas will also provide you much better fuel economy across the board compared to the much larger and heavier Yukon. Spare parts are plentiful for both between aftermarket and OEM providers, and most of the GT's body panels and interior trim/components are interchangeable with the much higher volume Chevy Tahoe's, but the front grille area parts for the Yukon GT may be getting harder to find and expensive. However, the 2-door Yukon GTs/Tahoes are getting very hard to find, especially very clean ones, so if you have the opportunity I would grab it!
 
Last edited:
Glad to hear you are doing better and now have your license again!

I had three 2-door Tahoes and wished I kept them (or at least one of them...lol). Two were the Sport model and therefore much like the Yukon GT with the monochromatic theme. I loved those trucks!

I set mine up with small lifts and larger, better tires and they were unflappable when going off-road, and downright fun in town as they actually handled very well despite their size with great turning feel and provided spritely acceleration due to very good HP and low end torque. They also could tow and haul greater loads due to their larger size and power/torque curves.

The 4Runners give you 4 doors with the same overall length, but also provide less headroom, shoulder room, and legroom compared to the 2-door Tahoe/Yukon. For example, a 1997 2-door Tahoe/GT had a 111.5-inch wheelbase with an overall length of 188 inches and 77.1 inches in overall width while the 4th Gen 4Runner had a 109.8-inch wheelbase with an overall length of 190 inches and 73.8 inches in overall width. However, having a 4Runner with 4 doors is quite an advantage as ingress/egress to the rear seats in the Yukon/Tahoes can be a challenge for some (but quite comfortable with large viewing side windows once back there); the 2-door Yukon rear windows obviously do not roll down which is another advantage of the 4-door 4Runner.

I think it's a toss-up on durability as the Chevy/GM in those years held up pretty well, but they also typically got beat up pretty good too which is why if I ever find one in terrific shape I would pick it up. The power- and drivetrains last forever like the 4runners. But I still have to say that the Toyota interior quality was a step ahead over the Chevy even in those years. As far as sunroofs go, you can also add a high quality aftermarket one like I did on my 2004 Tahoe Z71 and 2004 Dodge 2500; the larger trucks have plenty of headroom and roof space as to not interfere with the roof integrity and never had an issue with flex or leaks whatsoever.

Of the 3rd or 4th Gen Toyotas, they are absolutely great vehicles and will last forever if taken care of. I really like the 4th Gen looks and features with slightly more room and power over the 3rd Gen. The Toyotas will also provide you much better fuel economy across the board compared to the much larger and heavier Yukon. Spare parts are plentiful for both between aftermarket and OEM providers, and most of the GT's body panels and interior trim/components are interchangeable with the much higher volume Chevy Tahoe's, but the front grille area parts for the Yukon GT may be getting harder to find and expensive. However, the 2-door Yukon GTs/Tahoes are getting very hard to find, especially very clean ones, so if you have the opportunity I would grab it!

Thank You for that excellent input. I've been looking at 4th gen runners too, because you get a V8 and sunroof, plus they're newer and that Toyota build quality...but those damn Yukons are handsome and as a former hot-rod car guy, I'd love to do a 6.0/4L80E swap, maybe with a turbo, you can't really "hot-rod" the 4runner, but that might actually be a good thing....
 
Thank You for that excellent input. I've been looking at 4th gen runners too, because you get a V8 and sunroof, plus they're newer and that Toyota build quality...but those damn Yukons are handsome and as a former hot-rod car guy, I'd love to do a 6.0/4L80E swap, maybe with a turbo, you can't really "hot-rod" the 4runner, but that might actually be a good thing....


Yeah, a 4th Gen 4Runner with the V8 would be very hard to turn down. Having said that, a really clean Yukon GT 2-door with the much larger V8 and higher sitting position is great too; I have to agree that they are great looking trucks and something I would go after myself.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,317
Messages
3,554,128
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top