I am going to go with the XRC-8. The first couple years they had some issues but now the reviews are really good. Also need to consider how often you are going to use it per year. I recently went wheeling with a guy who had one and asked him how it was holding up considering the price difference between Smittybuilt and a Warn, Ramsey one. He wheels hard all over the US and said he uses it 30+ times a year(most are a few times every coulpe years) and has yet to have an issue. It is slower then some of the others but he is happy. Based on his review I am going to buy one.