Most of the information in your post, while good, is pure common sense that most people understand.
The point is simple: a 4.7 liter motor that makes 270 hp and 320 ft-lbs is VERY ordinary. Yes, we all get that these are made for trucks and we don't need 100 hp/lt or AMG-level torque, but those numbers are very underwhelming. I did test drive two of the V8s and while they seemed slightly more eager than the V6 (not denying that at all), it wasn't anything to make me want to say "I gotta have the V8"
Let me repeat it a third time. The 4.7 V8 is an ordinary motor that most people will say take it or leave it. No wonder it was killed off.
Numbers numbers. Where in the powerband does the V6 make its torque and where does the V8 make its? Well the V6 makes it at the high end of its power curve then it drops off quickly. The V8 makes it on the low end and holds it much longer. Put a heavy load behind both and the V8 will show you who is boss. Both are great motors and both have their downfalls. The 8 is pure smooth. I was going to get the V6, but before doing so i talked with a couple mechanics. One was a long time Toyota mechanic specializing in 4x4s and the other was an independant import mechanic. Both without hesitation said get the V8, it will last forever. It depends on what you do with your 4r and how long you keep it, but I dont think anyone can claim the V6 is superior to the V8.
Last edited: