05 sport calipers

basing110

New member
After going through the 5th gen and most other brake caliper threads still havent found a straight forward awnser.

I have a 05 sport edition so i have the bigger rotors and calipers. I believe my rear two calipers are sticking as my mpg has tanked to 14-15 mostly highway

Should i just get the 05 sport calipers or get 5th gen ones? Would the 5th gen be an upgrade as in built or designed better.
 
Register to hide this ad
From everything I have read, the 5th gen "upgrade" is acedemic at best. IMO I would just get new 4th gen calipers and some good rotors and pads and call it a day.
 
From everything I have read, the 5th gen "upgrade" is acedemic at best. IMO I would just get new 4th gen calipers and some good rotors and pads and call it a day.

SO far everything I've read indicates you are wrong. It is not uncommon for 4th gen replacement calipers to seize up again (OEM, aftermarket and/or remans). If you read over at the 5th gen section, very few report stuck calipers. The 5th gen 4Runner has been on sale for 7years now and it appears Toyota finally has fixed the problem. The thread on the 5th gen upgrade doesn't indicate anyone having problems either. I'm not sure what it is about the 5th gen calipers that they don't seize. They are bigger by mm (can't remember how much), but it can be a redesign of the piston seal. Someone also suggested that after several months, the area between the pads and piston a lot of debris accumulates. It was smartly suggested that one cleans out this area ever so often, but honestly who is going to do that?
[MENTION=135582]basing110[/MENTION] : go ahead and upgrade to the 5th grn calipers and if your wallet can handle it, do the front ones to avoid future aggravation. I'll be ordering my 5th gen calipers (all 4) very soon. Good luck!
 
3mm. And I was actually going to do a brake check and clean out that area next weekend. I though there had been some 5th gen calipers seized. If not great. Looks like a viable upgrade. I honestly was thinking in terms of better performance.
 
Last edited:
IMHO the seized caliper is an exaggerated problem. No doubt it happens but I don't see it as a pervasive problem. Yes, mine seized at 114,000 but what's the life expectation?
 
SO far everything I've read indicates you are wrong. It is not uncommon for 4th gen replacement calipers to seize up again (OEM, aftermarket and/or remans). If you read over at the 5th gen section, very few report stuck calipers. The 5th gen 4Runner has been on sale for 7years now and it appears Toyota finally has fixed the problem. The thread on the 5th gen upgrade doesn't indicate anyone having problems either. I'm not sure what it is about the 5th gen calipers that they don't seize. They are bigger by mm (can't remember how much), but it can be a redesign of the piston seal. Someone also suggested that after several months, the area between the pads and piston a lot of debris accumulates. It was smartly suggested that one cleans out this area ever so often, but honestly who is going to do that?

[MENTION=135582]basing110[/MENTION] : go ahead and upgrade to the 5th grn calipers and if your wallet can handle it, do the front ones to avoid future aggravation. I'll be ordering my 5th gen calipers (all 4) very soon. Good luck!

Our dealership has replaced calipers on newer Toyotas, including the 4Runner for seizing. It's not super common, but it does happen.

I also have seen one or two 5th gens with Les Schwab calipers indicating they seized and were done there (ironically those, like a lot of aftermarket ones seem to seize faster).
 
Last edited:
I bought my truck from a moderately salty environment (mountains of NC). 3 of 4 calipers were frozen.

I swapped 4 calipers and 4 rotors out. Less than a year later I had a rear caliper freeze again!

I swapped all 4 corners to 5th gen brakes and now live deep in the heart of the rust belt.

I am basically a rolling experiment.

As [MENTION=66389]BlackWorksInc[/MENTION] and some others have stated deep in that 5th gen caliper swap thread, and also above, that they are seeing 5th gen calipers sieze. This started this past winter, I believe?

That chilled me because I really don't want to keep swapping these bad boys out annually forever (although I have it down to a science, I just hate painting them).

For the record I'm at 1.5 years on the 5th gen calipers, so my fingers are crossed.

It is always the inside lower piston on the front that siezes first, although one of my fronts had 2 or 3 frozen pistons. So to me that is where that salt spray is like a pressure washer bathing everything.

I just wish someone would create non steel pistons so we could upgrade them. It would literally take 10 min to swap those out and I truly believe the problem would be solved.

Fingers crossed! (5th gens definitely have better stopping power too, btw!)
 
3mm. And I was actually goofing to do a brake check and clean out that area next weekend. I though there had been some 5th gen calipers seized. If not great. Looks like a viable upgrade. I honestly was thinking in terms of better performance.

The 5th gen upgrade is looked at as eliminating the problem of seizing. Thus far, it seems to do this. As far as better braking performance, even though the pistons are larger, I still haven't seen objective data to support this. Those who have reported better braking appear to have had their brakes toasted before the swap, so anything is going to feel better, IMO.

IMHO the seized caliper is an exaggerated problem. No doubt it happens but I don't see it as a pervasive problem. Yes, mine seized at 114,000 but what's the life expectation?

Good point and I agree. (reminds me of the HG "problem" in that it doesn't happen to all of us with V6s) I'd like to know what the life expectancy of the calipers are too. Sometime I just assume that this wear and tear item is going to happen and we should deal with it (those of us in the rust belt). That's fine. If changing to brakes that are more resilient to getting seized, then I think its a good option.

Our dealership has replaced calipers on newer Toyotas, including the 4Runner for seizing. It's not super common, but it does happen.

I also have seen one or two 5th gens with Les Schwab calipers indicating they seized and were done there (ironically those, like a lot of aftermarket ones seem to seize faster).

No doubt it happens, I was trying to point out that this happens more with 4thgeners than the 5th. I wish I could post figures on this, but I can't. Again, I don't think the 4th gen is PLAGUED with this problem, but when it happens to you, you want to make sure it's doesn't happen again. I know many aftermarket offer "lifetime" warranty, but what's the point if you have to do it over and over? That would aggravate me to no end.

EDIT:

I bought my truck from a moderately salty environment (mountains of NC). 3 of 4 calipers were frozen.

I swapped 4 calipers and 4 rotors out. Less than a year later I had a rear caliper freeze again!

I swapped all 4 corners to 5th gen brakes and now live deep in the heart of the rust belt.

I am basically a rolling experiment.

As [MENTION=66389]BlackWorksInc[/MENTION] and some others have stated deep in that 5th gen caliper swap thread, and also above, that they are seeing 5th gen calipers sieze. This started this past winter, I believe?

That chilled me because I really don't want to keep swapping these bad boys out annually forever (although I have it down to a science, I just hate painting them).

For the record I'm at 1.5 years on the 5th gen calipers, so my fingers are crossed.

It is always the inside lower piston on the front that siezes first, although one of my fronts had 2 or 3 frozen pistons. So to me that is where that salt spray is like a pressure washer bathing everything.

I just wish someone would create non steel pistons so we could upgrade them. It would literally take 10 min to swap those out and I truly believe the problem would be solved.

Fingers crossed! (5th gens definitely have better stopping power too, btw!)

Urrghhhh. Well, I wish you luck. I still believe the 5th gen upgrade is still worth it. (doesn't cost more than replacing with 4th gen components via RockAuto). Better stopping power? I believe you, but I'd like to see performance specs. It wouldn't matter to me anyway, in theory it makes sense.

Question on cleaning up between the pads and pistons: What would you do? All I can think of is cleaning up any debris with a rag and spraying (silicone spray) on the pistons rings to help preserve them.............................. or am I completely wrong??? (can't you tell I'm not a mechanic ?? LOL)
 
Last edited:
[MENTION=50507]CookieRoe[/MENTION]

I don't know, we don't see all that many 4th gens for this issue in Bend. Honestly I'd say it's about even between all the Tundras, Tacomas, 4Runners, Siennas, ect. No one seems to have been more prevalent than the other this year from my observations.

To be honest, from what I understand of some guys who live in the salt belt and more wintery areas, this is something that affects all cars. My rough guess is that it's a combination of factors.

-Water in the Brake Fluid/Brake Fluid not being serviced regularly
-Salt used in Winter
-High Corrosion prone areas (Florida for example)
-The dust boot being pinched/compromised/torn when pistons are compressed when a brake service is done (allowing corrosion to build up under the dust boot).

I haven't had the opportunity to open a seized caliper and usually you only find out by jamming the piston way in there so popping them out is roughly a no-go (I tried to pop one with shop air once like you do when rebuilding them, didn't work.)
 
Urrghhhh. Well, I wish you luck. I still believe the 5th gen upgrade is still worth it. (doesn't cost more than replacing with 4th gen components via RockAuto). Better stopping power? I believe you, but I'd like to see performance specs. It wouldn't matter to me anyway, in theory it makes sense.

Question on cleaning up between the pads and pistons: What would you do? All I can think of is cleaning up any debris with a rag and spraying (silicone spray) on the pistons rings to help preserve them.............................. or am I completely wrong??? (can't you tell I'm not a mechanic ?? LOL)

I'd say 5-10 percent stronger feel at the pedal. Since mine were basically brand new and most of your braking comes from the front, and my rear started sticking months later, I feel like I had a good chance to measure/feel it. It's been a while though.

We probably will never see a track review of the before and after!!

My plan is semiannual cleaning of the calipers and relubing everything with Sil Glyde or similar.

Hell, I carefully painted the calipers with high temp BBQ paint. One year up here in a WI winter shredded half the paint on my drivers side. So at the very least I have to repaint all of them soon with much better prep and a brushed on caliper specific paint this time. It'll be a fun project.

I think that rust and crud causes the pistons to sieze when it gets under the boots. So it'll be a fight to keep them lubed and cleaned up I guess.
 
After going through the 5th gen and most other brake caliper threads still havent found a straight forward awnser.

I have a 05 sport edition so i have the bigger rotors and calipers. I believe my rear two calipers are sticking as my mpg has tanked to 14-15 mostly highway

Should i just get the 05 sport calipers or get 5th gen ones? Would the 5th gen be an upgrade as in built or designed better.


I Put on 5th gen calipers and rotors on the front back in September on my 05' sport. Hasn't been that long but, everything is great. if you get the centric calipers...make sure you paint them before you install. they will rust within a week.
 
[MENTION=50507]CookieRoe[/MENTION]

I don't know, we don't see all that many 4th gens for this issue in Bend. Honestly I'd say it's about even between all the Tundras, Tacomas, 4Runners, Siennas, ect. No one seems to have been more prevalent than the other this year from my observations.

To be honest, from what I understand of some guys who live in the salt belt and more wintery areas, this is something that affects all cars. My rough guess is that it's a combination of factors.

-Water in the Brake Fluid/Brake Fluid not being serviced regularly
-Salt used in Winter
-High Corrosion prone areas (Florida for example)
-The dust boot being pinched/compromised/torn when pistons are compressed when a brake service is done (allowing corrosion to build up under the dust boot).

I haven't had the opportunity to open a seized caliper and usually you only find out by jamming the piston way in there so popping them out is roughly a no-go (I tried to pop one with shop air once like you do when rebuilding them, didn't work.)

Living in the rust belt is terrible. As much as I love my rigs, (my Civic is holding up very well, after 10 years, I see little to no rust on chassis/components/etc). My 4R's chassis has a good amount of rust (surface), I'm aware it's only going to get worse as time goes on. My point: I'm starting to come to terms with "this is what is normal". I haven't ventured onto the 3rd or "classic" 4R section to see if they are suffering from seized calipers.

Thanks for your input!

I'd say 5-10 percent stronger feel at the pedal. Since mine were basically brand new and most of your braking comes from the front, and my rear started sticking months later, I feel like I had a good chance to measure/feel it. It's been a while though.

We probably will never see a track review of the before and after!!

My plan is semiannual cleaning of the calipers and relubing everything with Sil Glyde or similar.

Hell, I carefully painted the calipers with high temp BBQ paint. One year up here in a WI winter shredded half the paint on my drivers side. So at the very least I have to repaint all of them soon with much better prep and a brushed on caliper specific paint this time. It'll be a fun project.

I think that rust and crud causes the pistons to sieze when it gets under the boots. So it'll be a fight to keep them lubed and cleaned up I guess.

BBQ paint? LOL. Brakes must smell awesome on a hot day! .................. Sil Glyde, eh? Gonna check that out! Thanks!

I Put on 5th gen calipers and rotors on the front back in September on my 05' sport. Hasn't been that long but, everything is great. if you get the centric calipers...make sure you paint them before you install. they will rust within a week.

Way ahead of ya! I haven't ordered the calipers yet (this week). I have G2 paint (silver) I got from Amazon. $47 for paint.......... yikes........... Anyway, I'll be posting pics on the "5thgen brake upgrade" thread.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,315
Messages
3,554,104
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top