untrue statement
you do know that the inboard cv joint is only held in place on the cv from the boot
OK, perhaps I was a bit vague on that statement. As read, yes, I can see where you could come up with that conclusion.
Keep in mind that the CV axle was "acting up" in other ways. One, it would have a metal-to-metal noise when going over bumps and small potholes...easily heard. Two, it would have a rotational "swish, swish, swish" noise when moving slowly through the neighborhood. Three, it would have a vibration or shudder upon acceleration from a stop until about 25mph...but still had a small vibration felt in the steering wheel at highway speed. Four, the first 30 yards, or so, of travel through the neighborhood in the morning, it would have a rotational "squeak, squeak, squeak", then go away.
It did not have the "click, click, click" when making a tight turn.
When I went underneath and grabbed the axle shaft, yes, there is supposed to be a fair amount of play, but specifically, when I shook it, I was recieving a lot of metal-to-metal vibration that I could feel in my hand, as well as, hear. Something that was not felt on the other axle on the other side, and certainly was not felt with the new axle, once installed.
I hope this clears it up.