icantsee said:I've seen 1/8" or even 1/16" before.
You got 58,000 miles on one set of brake pads...that' well over expectation.
You're at 1/4" & it's squeaking, maybe the wear indicator is scratching the rotor already.
It's cheaper to replace the brake pads then to replace the brake rotors, plus, you'll feel safer knowing that the brake pads are new.
I had Honda Accord, Honda Civic & Toyota Camry...and replaced the brake pads around 30,000