After receiving the carpet samples from both automotive interiors and quality car interior, I decided that automotive interiors had the better plush cut pile carpet and also more color choices. So I ordered up the molded carpet for $255.
If you're thinking about replacing your carpet, which I highly recommend, do beware! The aftermarket manufacturers have replacement recommended colors that do NOT match your OEM color. Not even close. Automotive Interiors recommends 9577 Medium Dark Oak but as you can see from the below photos, it's no match at all to the OEM color. Luckily since I had ordered about a dozen samples, I discovered the 906 Sandstone/Came color was a near spot on match and in my opinion, is a better color to the OEM since it more closely matches the dark brown interior trim pieces.
I can't say enough about the quality of this aftermarket carpet; it's superior to Toyota's. The fibers are thicker, even & more plush and the stitch pattern is barely visible. Notice on the OEM how you can clearly see the stitch pattern lines. The one nice thing the OEM has is slightly better padding on the bottom but this is really negligible. It also comes with a hard rubber heal pad, something the old OEM did not have.
Cutting and installation took about 5 hours. I started out by placing the new carpet on top of the old and made sure to fit the molded areas between the two for an accurate overlay. I drew a rough outline of the pattern with chalk and cut away with a sharp box cutter. Once the shape was cut roughly and leaving the edges a little larger, I moved it into the car, ensured the molded areas were pressed in place correctly, cut the console area out, cut outer edges down to size, then moved on to the details like the bolt holes, etc. The hardest part was cutting around the rear seat floor hump where the rear vent and console protrudes. It's very easy to cut too much here so I recommend testing fitting your center consol/arm rest/rear heater piece before cutting.
I couldn't be happier with the results. Next is the cargo area!