I drank the coolaid. But I also have a numbers/analytical mind. I had three tanks of numbers before I cut my air box. I can tell you with all honesty that the only thing it did for me was to increase engine bay noise and decrease the milage... by 3 mpg! And I had done new plugs and the Sea Foam cleanout for oil (BTW holy crap the SF it works. I had just put brand new oil in it. after 200 miles, I drained it. It was black as midnight. The engine is definitely happier).
I sealed it right back up and this tank is already showing improved gas milage. I never saw any increase in power/pickup, or acceleration. Besides, there is a nice little button I call "lets waste gas-a go-go". It does help with acceleration, but this is done thru the computer to change air-fuel ratio's, and shift points I assume. (the best part is its wasting gas on demand only)
Just my opinion on the coolaid, and some first hand numbers to work off of.