Do not go to dealership for oil change!

When the dealer "threw in" Toyota Care for free oil changes on our new 2019 4Runner I was not impressed. After reading multiple 4Runner forums I will either do them myself or find a local indie shop, though a local indie shop put new snow tires on my wife's vehicle and 2 of them were not installed directionally proper...

On the other hand, every single service we had done at the Audi dealers when we owned Audi's was exceptional with never a problem - late model loaners, coffee, juice, snacks, fruit, car washes, and always solved the issue, even odd squeeks and rattles that only occurred in certain circumstances.

Audi Care for all maintenance up to 50,000 miles was a good choice then.

Go online and you’ll find plenty of people *****ing about Audi dealers too. No one goes to write a good post about a routine maintenance. Most routine stuff is done by inexperienced guys regardless of the shop. Experienced mechanics are busy handling bigger issues. The relatively small number of complaints you read (many of which are just “i read this somewhere” and not first hand experience) compared to the hundreds of thousands of vehicles serviced isn’t statistically significant. I’ve had multiple vehicles serviced at multiple locations and never experienced any big issues. Late model loaners, coffee, juice, snacks, fruit, and car washes are something any dealer I’ve ever been to offers, regardless of the brand.
 
Just the tranny pan was dropped. Not the whole transmission. They said the way they tell it's full is from the top of the pan. They have a nut or tube that drains when it's over filled. Once it stops draining, it's full.

Why Toyota removed the trans dip stick is a mystery. It's like they force you to go get it done at a dealership.

My other question is when does a 5th Gen need to get it's tranny fluid replaced via maintenance schedule? 30k miles?

The current system is better for trans life, makes getting fluid level dead on about foolproof. They don't even have to drop the pan, just open plug for tube that sets fluid level, pump fluid in fill hole until it starts running out, close drain, run vehicle up to temp, and open level tube drain again until fluid slows to a trickle.

Anyone can do this themselves with Torque app to read the temp, or there's a shift pattern you can do, like between N and D 5 times in 10 seconds or something like that, forget exactly, and when trans is at correct temp to drain overfill a dash light flashes

You can do a full trans flush by yourself in the driveway in about an hour, and then you'll know it's not just a drain and refill like most shops will do. Believe factory trans fluid change is spec'd to 70k, 30k ish used to be for heavy towing only and prob more these days with WS fluid. Don't skip trans flushes!
 
Go online and you’ll find plenty of people *****ing about Audi dealers too. No one goes to write a good post about a routine maintenance. Most routine stuff is done by inexperienced guys regardless of the shop. Experienced mechanics are busy handling bigger issues. The relatively small number of complaints you read (many of which are just “i read this somewhere” and not first hand experience) compared to the hundreds of thousands of vehicles serviced isn’t statistically significant. I’ve had multiple vehicles serviced at multiple locations and never experienced any big issues. Late model loaners, coffee, juice, snacks, fruit, and car washes are something any dealer I’ve ever been to offers, regardless of the brand.

I'm not discounting that others are *****ing about Audi dealers (or Ford, or Chevy, or Alpha Romeo, or BMW, or Tesla, or ...)

I'm just relating my personal experience over 12 years of Audi ownership, 2008 - present (and 4 separate dealers) discounting the "No one goes to write a good post about a routine maintenance". I'm still driving the most trouble free car I've ever owned (a 12 year old 2008 Audi A4, 3.2L, 6MT).

I've visited the 3 Toyota dealers to try to purchase stuff from their parts counters and have service done for over 20 years that I owned my FJ60, 1999-2019, and the personal experiences have continuously gotten worse. I bought the 2019 4Runner because of what I need and want to use it for, dealer service quality notwithstanding.

My local Toyota dealers do not offer the "waiting room" experience that every Audi dealer has, so my data point on that may well differ from others.

Keep up the good dialog though. It's good to know my experiences are not necessarily the norm.
 
Wow what a nightmare for the OP. Completely unnecessary and avoidable if the dealer had done the right job but they are notorious for screwing oil changes up. This confirms why the dealer will never see my Runner unless it's for a warranty issue or recall.
 
Last edited:
Yea, i couldnt make up this story if i tried. Spent most of my morning today power washing my driveway in 40F degree weather. Jesus... baking soda & dish liquid... over and over a few times....i swear, i better not have a fresh oil stain tomorrow morning or else i will flip out. :doh:

IMG_20200123_220204_zpssvm41g3w.jpg


** If you noticed it says (6) qt of Mobil1 on the service ticket above.

IMG_20200123_220226_zpsbuheafws.jpg


*** Now look at what it says above on this service ticket.. (6) qt of 0w20 BULK OIL-W and 1 qt of Mobil1. What are they using 0w20 BULK OIL-W for? Makes me think they drained all my Mobil1 Oil, added their shitty synthetic blend, and added 1 quart of Mobil1? I'm Confused :confused:

Oil on the top, Tranny fluid on the bottom...courtesy of Sansone Toyota.

IMG_20200122_092710_zpsowks2gou.jpg
 
Last edited:
Problem with the dealerships performing oil changes it's usually a "general service" tech with little to no knowledge of automotive repairs. Unfortunately most shops do not have lead techs or service mgr. to oversee newbies doing low level automotive repairs.

I’ve seen way too many “Master techs” work as sloppy as the newbies. Nobody takes pride in their work anymore, and those titles are bestowed up them means nothing.
 
On a positive note we’re lucky our oil pans aren’t made out of aluminum, stripped threads when a torque wrench was nowhere to be found.
 

Attachments

  • 4D7572FD-4B6A-424F-963E-40C52227F346.jpg
    4D7572FD-4B6A-424F-963E-40C52227F346.jpg
    133.8 KB · Views: 1,484
You guys are scaring me with these horror stories. I've got almost 3000 miles on mine. I'll have an oil change coming soon. I work with a guy who bought his 2019 Tacoma at the same dealership as me. I'll definitely be asking him about their service department. He gets all his maintenance work done there.
 
You guys are scaring me with these horror stories. I've got almost 3000 miles on mine. I'll have an oil change coming soon.

Dude, go to a Mobil1 and get it done there if you can't change it yourself.. This thread isn't meant to scare you but to create awareness. If you do a search on T4R you will see there are many mishaps at the dealership. But I think this one takes the cake. The only thing a dealer should do is recall work or something under warranty.

It used to be local mechanics were grease monkies and dealerships did quality work. Now it seems reversed.
 
On a positive note we’re lucky our oil pans aren’t made out of aluminum, stripped threads when a torque wrench was nowhere to be found.

No kidding. Sheesh!

You know, I've never used a torque wrench for an oil change but yet I've never stripped a drain plug. I swear, some of these techs must use nothing but a pneumatic impact wrench for anything.
 
So... Pull the plates?

Yep, they removed the skid plates. And you're not going to believe this, I see a small oil stain on my driveway again, under the TRD Skid plate. I'm so angry right now.

Hoping it is old oil that was laying in the TRD skid plate from them not tightening the oil filter housing.

IMG_20200124_093710_zpszjduxoaf.jpg


Crawled under the runner, i saw some oil on the bottom of the TRD Skidplate and you can see a fresh leak on my driveway. Wiped it off. Looked inside the skidplate, and looked at the oil filter housing. Seemed dry. Will keep my eye on it.
 
Last edited:
Yep, they removed the skid plates. And you're not going to believe this, I see a small oil stain on my driveway again, under the TRD Skid plate. I'm so angry right now.

Hoping it is old oil that was laying in the TRD skid plate from them not tightening the oil filter housing.

If not, I'm going to bring it to a friend who is a mechanic and finally get it fixed right. Should of went to him in the first place.
Call Toyota and open a case.
 
I wanted to verify the dealer was replacing the oil filter. I assumed they would remove the plastic splash guard between the bumper and stock metal splash guard that's held in place by 5 wide flange fender style bolts. So, I used my wife's nail polish to paint a glob on the edge of the two forward outer bolt flanges to indicate if those bolts were broken loose.

The globs were not broken, so I showed it to the shop manager. He said, they only remove four metal guard bolts and let the metal guard hang by the forward hooks while changing the oil filter. At home, I removed the metal splash guard and found it had been wiped down to remove a streak of oil that flowed down and back from the oil filter location.

That's when I started doing my own oil changes because I think allowing the metal guard to hang and flex the plastic splash guard will eventually crack the plastic.

I had to chase the four metal guard bolt threads with a tap and die, and fortunately, all of them appear to be OK.
 
Yep, they removed the skid plates. And you're not going to believe this, I see a small oil stain on my driveway again, under the TRD Skid plate. I'm so angry right now.

Back to my original point. If you're concerned with them jacking up the skid plate bolts... Pull them yourself. Need to come down to clean the oil off them anyway.
 
After a "Routine" oil change / tire rotation service, as I was leaving the dealership, the front-right tire came off. They FORGOT to tighten the lug-nuts!!

Fortunately the damage was minimal - they had to replace the TRD wheel because it was scratched on the inside. On the bright-side, I had them give me the "damaged" wheel and I plan on using it as a second spare for long off-road trips.
 
DougR what dealer in Phoenix did you experience the crummy work?
Was it the dealer in Peoria?
Thanks

Camelback Toyota in Phoenix. It's my wife's vehicle and she wanted the dealer to do all routine maintenance while it was under warranty. Now it's under my care :cowboy:
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,317
Messages
3,554,129
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top