I picked up a trail teams edition in 2008. I liked driving it... made me feel like I was driving a tank and could go anywhere I wanted... but the ex-wife hated it.
Here are my complaints about it.
1. Its surprisingly small inside. The back seat is totally useless, and for the most part I had the dog in the back, which means all your storage is on the rear seat.
2. Its lousy as a highway cruiser. I felt I was limited to 110km/hr. Anything above that and the gas mileage dropped off drastically. And the wind noise... gahd.
3. The C-Pillar design. If you get spotter mirrors it helps some, but any quick lane changes are near impossible. Get used to checking your blind spot over and over again. The C-pillar can and will hide anything smaller than a house.
4. The rear door... if you need to use the back seat, make sure there is no one near you. So you'll be parking at the back of any parking lot. You will get stuck in the door triangle a few times before learning your lesson.
5. If you enjoy the scenery while driving... the visibility out of the FJ will make you miss 90% of what road trips are all about. I drove the Oregon coast in 2011 with it... missed most of the scenery. Drove it again last year in the 4runner and what a difference.
6. The stock roof rack is almost useless... but that's with most factory roof racks. Upgrade to make it useful.
7. It needs a rear view camera. Mine didn't have one... minor point, but it would have been better if it came with one.
8. No sunroof... we only have 2 weeks of summer in Calgary... it would be nice to enjoy the sun while driving.
9. Cheap plastic material everywhere. I often had lumber poking out through rear window. The interior was scratched to hell.
10. You'll go through windshields often.... and they weren't cheap.
11. Soft paint... but that's like everything else on the market now that paint is water based.
What I did like...
1. It is a very capable vehicle. Right from the start, you'll want to drive over stuff.... well I did anyways. But it was also my first true
2. It looks awesome. I really like the all white with blacked out trim (2008+)and all black editions (2007 TRD).
3. It was small enough to discourage people from sitting in the back... no in-laws tagging along.
4. Excellent in the winter. First spring I had it, we had a freak snow storm around Easter. 12-15" of snow in a couple hours. The city shut down... I just plowed on through.
5. Really easy to work on. Lots of room in the engine bay for a compressor, battery, etc. And easiest oil changes I've done anything with 4 wheels.
6. The FJ forum was the first friendly forum I joined. Lots of helpful people there, and a great community. Learned lots of what to do and not do.
7. Lots of aftermarket support.
8. Based on Tacoma chassis and powertrain. The good ones, not the new crap that Toyota seems to be churning out.