Ya I'm confused too. I have the Gibson and I think it's quiet, drone free, and the sound I hear is pleasant and soothing going down the road. It still makes me grin when I get on it knowing that it has a nice deep growl outside. The only thing I can say for you is that you need to cut it out and weld a stock muffler in. If this one bothers you then you'll never find one you like. It is the most mellow, has a nice growl and isn't raspy, and any other aftermarket muffler is going to drone, be to loud and just make you unhappy.