Gobi Rack - Advantage and disadvantages

I'm all about patent stopping patent trolling, but you are misrepresenting their patent.

Here are their relevent patents from the whitson case:
https://www.google.com/patents/USD578952
https://www.google.com/patents/USD520938

Here are the claims:
"The ornamental design for a sport utility vehicle rack, as shown and described."
and
"The ornamental design for a multi-purpose storage rack for a sport utility vehicle, as shown and described."

the "as shown and described" part references the images that they have showing their design. Their patent is not for any any design or look, only what looks like their figures. their ladder design is also an ornamental design patent.

they do not have any patents that i can find that pertain to how the rack attaches (in fact they don't even claim the foot tabs in their patent), their patent is about how racks look. they own that rack design.

that doesn't look like patent trolling to me, it looks like them protecting their design



It actually is the exact definition of patent trolling with the vagueness of what they patented the lawsuits are endless as we can clearly see. The patent was for vehicle specific racks, and again last time I checked they weren't the first to build a roof rack? And this was discussed in full detail between several engineers, fabricators, and lawyers. (If you read the threads in their entirety you would see this)
What it looks like to everyone else is them stomping healthy competition so they can have a monopoly on the market. Just ask Jason Demello who stated the same thing and deals with DO knockoffs all the time. The best way around it is improving your product and getting by on a great reputation. Gobi did it so they could continue price gouging and get away with shitty customer service and a subpar product.
But if you want to sit and justify that purchase that's fine but how the whole suit unraveled isn't justifiable. Cheers to you though brother. Enjoy the rack
 
Last edited:
It actually is the exact definition of patent trolling with the vagueness of what they patented the lawsuits are endless as we can clearly see. The patent was for vehicle specific racks, and again last time I checked they weren't the first to build a roof rack?
But if you want to sit and justify that purchase that's fine but how the whole suit unraveled isn't justifiable. Cheers to you though brother. Enjoy the rack
It's not vehicle specific, the claims I listed are the only claims on the patent.

I even linked to the patent, view it for yourself, it is an ornamental patent for the design. They patented their design, the look

Sent from my HTC6525LVW using Tapatalk
 
It's not vehicle specific, the claims I listed are the only claims on the patent.

I even linked to the patent, view it for yourself, it is an ornamental patent for the design. They patented their design, the look

Sent from my HTC6525LVW using Tapatalk



So you didn't read the comparison between the two racks? Or recently see how Gobi embarrassed themselves while going after Baja and they were called out for misrepresentation and had their dates wrong. Solid.
 
Last edited:
So you didn't read the comparison between the two racks? Solid.
I was replying to your misunderstanding of their patent, you seemed to have a misunderstanding of ornamental patents

Edit:
read the other thread, i think a lot of the confusion is because both the lawsuit and patent were inaccurately summarized in that thread

Sent from my HTC6525LVW using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
I was replying to your misunderstanding of their patent, you seemed to have a misunderstanding of ornamental patents

Edit:
read the other thread, i think a lot of the confusion is because both the lawsuit and patent were inaccurately summarized in that thread

Sent from my HTC6525LVW using Tapatalk

I actually fully understand both. Also saw and personally discussed with ID2000 and what they were doing to their competitors and how they were going about it. No matter how you cut it I still wouldn't promote someone with poor business practices like them. But again up to you to justify your own actions and turn a blind eye. :hatsoff:
 
if you have evidence that they didn't create that design, show that prior art and their patent can be invalidated
 
Let's see some more pictures! Need my daily dose of 4Runner porn :boink: :worthless

Also, still no disadvantages!? Selling me on this rack even more.
 
The only disadvantage is the wait time which is almost 3 months. Be sure to do your research before ordering (no rise? Want the option to put on a 40" light bar at a later time?, etc.).
 
lol

e60ral, you are not going to convince those that don't want to be convinced but I applaud your attempt at facts and gathering some info. To that point, I don't have to justify sh!t to anybody on this board and my eyes are not blind. Love what I got and I'm going to use it whenever I can. I hope others love the rack they have and do the same.
 
I have only used mine for looks and still think its worth it

Disadvantage:
Higher Priced
MPG

Advantage:
Higher resale value, well known rack
Who cares about MPG
Look
Function
Quality
 
Let's see some more pictures! Need my daily dose of 4Runner porn :boink: :worthless

Also, still no disadvantages!? Selling me on this rack even more.

The only disadvantage is the wait time which is almost 3 months. Be sure to do your research before ordering (no rise? Want the option to put on a 40" light bar at a later time?, etc.).

Disadvantages:
Cost
MPG hit
Wind noise
Much harder to wash and wax roof
If not installed carefully can increase chance of water leak
They rust eventually, sometimes from the inside out.
Wait times have sometimes gone as long as 6 months, while promising less
Increased height for garages
You will spend even more money on things to bolt onto and carry in it
Your wife will think it's weird that people compliment your rack...
 
ddaf20cca6c4e4057327a5fae66223a2.jpg
i love mine- it took 12 weeks to get tho


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Are the excessive wait times through distributers like Trail and Duty or direct from Gobi? Group buy related?
 
Last edited:
Gobi

Are the excessive wait times through distributers like Trail and Duty or direct from Gobi? Group buy related?

I think the wait time is all the same. I think you can count on 10-12 weeks on average. You may order from Trail Duty but I think its drop shipped straight from Gobi. Hell, I just ordered the Gobi ARB awning mounts from Trail Duty and they are having them shipped direct from Gobi.
 
Can anyone shed some light on how much height, if any, the Gobi Stealth adds to the truck? Not sure if I will be able to park in my garage anymore if I put one on lol....
 
Gobi No Rise

Can anyone shed some light on how much height, if any, the Gobi Stealth adds to the truck? Not sure if I will be able to park in my garage anymore if I put one on lol....

Before someone flames you for not searching around I will tell you that unless you have an abnormally small garage opening or a big lift on your 4runner then you will be fine parking in your garage even if you get the normal rise Gobi rack. There are pictures on this board of the 4runners with Gobi's in garages. Hell, I put a Yakama load warrior basket on the stock roof rails and it fit easy and that combo is a lot taller than any Gobi from the roofline. Hope this helps.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,316
Messages
3,554,107
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top