OP sorry I missed this thread man. I am from Durango and actually my house is just up the road from where you stayed, on Old Lime Creek Road. Wish I would have seen this, as there is not a single dirt road, or offshoot in that area that I am unfamiliar with. I'll bump over to your build thread to check out your pictures.
And here is another account of what happened.
https://outdoorx4.com/main/2015/08/04/rollover-on-black-bear-pass-during-100s-in-the-hills/
Sounds like the lazy sheriff of 35 years needs to be kicked out of office. Maybe he has been on the gravy train too long. Lord knows Telluride has some money flowing. At least they could be equipped for a simple rough terrain rescue... The entire story makes no sense to me. The area must have backcountry EMS type calls all the time. Something is not adding up.
Dude...Those are some harsh words, and some pretty heavy assumptions for someone that is unfamiliar with the area and the situation. "simple rough terrain rescue" Do you have any idea how sheer and Exposed the San Juans are? There is absolutely nothing simple about hauling someones rolled vehicle out of even the smallest of terrain traps up there. Telluride is extremely isolated, they don't have the personnel and equipment to mobilize a task force every time some geriatric fat ass from out of town rolls his side by side (I hate them too) off the cliff and causes a serious traffic problem in the high country.
That incident backed traffic up all the way to the summit, which is over 5 miles by the way. Think about that for a minute. 100s of cars hundreds of people more or less stuck because of one idiot. What if weather moved in? what if someone else got hurt up there? It is a tiny town, in some of the most rugged terrain in the country. Easy to arm chair quarterback that one and say the Sheriff is on some kind of vendetta against off roaders, which isn't the case, though I can't say that I would blame him if he were. Seeing the way the *******s from NM and Arizona come up and treat my state I often ashamed to be remotely associated with them. But I just bring extra trash bags on the trails and pick up what I can.
I'm not attacking you here man, Just please know that there are two sides to every coin.
I have spoken with Bill Masters. Two friends and I got lost skiing in Bear Creek on day. We slogged 1500 vert in tits deep snow back into ski area bounds aroun 930pm where ski patrol and SAR was looking for us. When we got to town Sheriff Masters had some choice words for us, as did the director of ski patrol and some others. He is a good man, and he has a lot on his plate.
Now I will be the first to agree that Telluride has more tools than Home Depot, but he isn't one of them.
Sorry for the windy bump of an old thread, this topic just kind of struck a chord.
And for the record, Black Bear Pass is extremely unlikely to be shut down anytime soon. The amount of revenue it brings to the town and the area is quite high, but anything can happen. It isn't the first time he has called for it.
The best thing to do is when you go, please clean up after yourselves, pack out more than you pack in and be respectful to the area.