Don't recommend
This was a frustrating adventure, but I learned a lot in the process.
I recently purchased some 285/75/16 E Treadwright Wardens. They don't offer many of their tires in anything below a D. I figured having the E rating would help with punishing the tires offroad and all the weight from rooftop tent and other camping gear.
The necessary wheel spacers, lift, and fender trimming commenced. When installed, they rubbed on the upper control arm, then after spacers they rubbed on the rear part of the front wheel well.
I had Discount Tire mount and balance them. I loved the look of a larger tire and something that was more aggressive than my last set. After a day or two of infatuation wore off, I got upset with the ride quality--there was an annoying vibration.
Second trip to Discount Tire to see if they could rebalance. They did a static balance and the ride improved, but still a little bouncy because one tire took a ton of weight to balance.
I chatted with Treadwright and their amazing customer service rep immediately sent me a new tire. Third trip to Discount tire to have it mounted and balanced. As I drove away, I shook my head and almost cried. Still shaking.
I THEN went to a specialty off-road shop figuring they would have a better machine and more experience in balancing larger tires. I think they had a road force machine... ? Anyway they told me one tire is out of round.
Called Treadwright again and the guy explained that an E rated tire is probably too heavy for a 3rd Gen 4runner. Something like an F250 is heavy enough to mitigate the rotating weight shaking at speed. I hadn't considered that an E rated tire would be too heavy since so many people mount them. And often the 33s or larger aren't available in lower than E rating. Then I recalled the FedEx shipping notification: 66lbs per tire!
Even if it's not true that E rated tires are too heavy for a 4runner, these particular tires were. And they weren't high quality enough to avoid vibrations. I'm getting these tires sent back. This was my experience, hopefully, yours is less of a hassle.
Anyone want to buy 5 Treadwright Wardens 285/75/16 E ??
Conclusion:
- 4 trips to a tire shop
- Crappy ride quality
- Don't recommend E rating (D might be okay)
- Now I have to get them shipped back to Treadwright or sold on CL
- After all the hassle, I wish I had gone with a different tire in the first place
Solution:
- 265/75/16 C Goodyear Wrangler Duratracs (45lbs each!)
- also, the smaller and lighter weight tire improved handling, acceleration, and braking
- with a more aggressive looking but smaller tire and wheel spacers + lift, the stance still looks awesome!
That'll teach me to go cheap again. The Duratracs are SUCH a better tire compared to the Treadwrights. Hope this review helps!