Any tire guy is going to tell you to replace all four. It's safe advice and he sells more tires. Truth is, the difference in revs/mile is so small that there would be little effect on the center diff. provided you stay with the same size. There are slight variations from one manufacturer to another in overall diameter of tires of the same size, as well as differences in the same tire built in different plants, all of which are bery small. For example the diameter of a 265/65/17 may be 30.6" from one mfr and 30.53" from another.