Hmm. Must have never pulled many engines apart. Carbon buildup happens, period, whether you burn premium all the time or not. Using an additive is a good way to aid in dissolving carbon when you only run 2-3 tanks of premium through a vehicle a year. Let's face it, if it weren't for carbon buildup, we'd likely get several hundred thousand miles out of every set of generic non-platinum spark plugs. You just have to make sure anything you add to your gas doesn't contain much if any chlorine - other than that, they'er fine.
Like I said, using Lucas (or a brand of your choosing) and adding in some premium (with its higher detergent content) works great for keeping the buildup to a minimum. I've seen it first hand in several street-car V8 teardown/rebuilds I've done over the past decade.
I know the carbon is a problem when I tear town my race car's V8 every other month during racing season...of course, the sanctioning body that I race under doesn't allow fuel additives or it wouldn't be as bad.