I've also tried the Eagle One "wax as u dry". Personally I think it worked about the same as the "quick wax". I do like Eagle One products though. I use their wheel cleaner (forget what it's called) and it seems to work really well. As far as all of the quick or easy waxes go, they all work about the same. Just like with vehicles people tend to get "brand biased" depending on what they've been using. In my experience with all of the quick waxes I've used, they all need reapplied after it rains. I've had an awesome shine with both Eagle One and Meguiars temporarily. Main thing is you need to have a base coat of real wax for any of these to work as they're supposed too.