Seems to make little sense to buy used

diver110

New member
I have been watching new and used prices for a while. Assuming the asking price of used cars is in the ballpark of the selling price (which may be a large assumption), generally it does not make sense to buy used, unless you catch a deal. A very typical example in Autotrader: 2008 4runner, 4x4 $27,000, 43,400 miles (not a limited but with a power seat). Let's say the dealer will go down to $25,000. For another 13,000 or so, you can get a new 2011 trail edition, since they are selling them close to invoice--and that comes with newer technology and 10% better gas mileage. Assuming you can afford the ticket to play, to me a new one is a better value (albeit with a bit higher insurance toll). I have noticed this same fact with other Toyotas.

The other noteworthy fact is that at least in my area most recent 4runners are being sold by dealers, not private parties. The ones sold by private parties are usually much older. This may be a good sign that people are happy with their 4runners and don't sell them too often.
 
Register to hide this ad
I bought my 04 used and saved 5k off the new price back in 04 I drove it for 6 years and loved every min of it but I had been wanting the new Trail Edition ever since they released what it would be. My Trail was at my dealer for a whole 1 1/2 days before I bought it and they haven't had another one. I Love my new 4Runner but really enjoyed my old one as well. I do think used is a good idea if you find a deal because of deprecation. As for insurance mine went up a whole 2 bucks a month
 
That was the same conclusion I came to as we... For me, I was planning on keeping the truck for a while 6+ years and could afford either a new or a used 4runner. The 2011 Trail Edition I ended up with seemed like a far better deal. Brand new, full warranty, recently updated = no brainer...
 
I bought my 04 used and saved 5k off the new price back in 04 I drove it for 6 years and loved every min of it but I had been wanting the new Trail Edition ever since they released what it would be. My Trail was at my dealer for a whole 1 1/2 days before I bought it and they haven't had another one. I Love my new 4Runner but really enjoyed my old one as well. I do think used is a good idea if you find a deal because of deprecation. As for insurance mine went up a whole 2 bucks a month

It would depend how many miles it had, 10,000, yeah, save the 5K, 15,000, not so sure, 20,000 definitely would rather buy new.
 
It would depend how many miles it had, 10,000, yeah, save the 5K, 15,000, not so sure, 20,000 definitely would rather buy new.

My 04 had like 9k on it but when I deploy it sits for 6 months at a time so mileage didn't really matter to me my Trail I got new just cause they had it. My dealer has like 6 used 2010's and 2 new ones and I guess if they don't have what you want new you buy used considering the closest Toyota dealer is over 300+ miles away at least that's the way it is here
 
Last edited:
My 04 had like 9k on it but when I deploy it sits for 6 months at a time so mileage didn't really matter to me my Trail I got new just cause they had it. My dealer has like 6 used 2010's and 2 new ones and I guess if they don't have what you want new you buy used considering the closest Toyota dealer is over 300+ miles away at least that's the way it is here

That's a good point. If you are far from a dealer, different analysis.
 
Bought my 2010 Trail certified used with 14,500 miles. Paid $28K, which I thought was a pretty good deal, esp. with 2.9% financing.
 
Bought my 2010 Trail certified used with 14,500 miles. Paid $28K, which I thought was a pretty good deal, esp. with 2.9% financing.

Where i live there is a certified used trail w/kdss and nav w/4k miles for 38,999. Not sure how much they will come down but you can get a new one at invoice for less then that. They also have a 10 limited w/6K miles 3rd row no nav for same price. Too much if you ask me.
 
Where i live there is a certified used trail w/kdss and nav w/4k miles for 38,999. Not sure how much they will come down but you can get a new one at invoice for less then that. They also have a 10 limited w/6K miles 3rd row no nav for same price. Too much if you ask me.

I see those kind of prices a lot. Don't make sense to me either. Maybe they are betting on someone coming along who has not found this board.:lmao:
 
Hi all, just bought a 2011 sr5. I can't wait to pick it up later today! Anyway, I had a number from a friend. He bought a used 07 a few years ago. I think only a few thousand miles. I got $200 more than he paid with a tradein and tax / fees included. So, I figure I got a good deal and I wanted the warranties, maintenance, etc.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,317
Messages
3,554,127
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top