Should electronic stability control be mandatory?

Thai

Elite Member
By Paul Williams

Ottawa, Ontario - After learning of another fatal crash in my area -- this one involving a small pickup truck and its four occupants, three of whom died -- I knew that the vehicle subject vehicle, a Ford Ranger, wasn't equipped with Electronic Stability Control (ESC). I know this because ESC is not standard equipment on the Ranger, nor is it offered as an option.

Would ESC have helped? Results from surveys and research all over the world are confirming that ESC has a significant impact on the outcome of crashes involving loss of control (which account for nearly half the road crashes in Canada). According to Transport Canada, "Preliminary analyses of data for calendar years 2000 to 2005 indicate that ESC could have prevented approximately 30 per cent of fatal and injury crashes that involved loss of control, if all vehicles in Canada had been equipped with ESC." That would amount to a reduction of nearly 1,000 fatalities.

Research from the U.S.-based Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) supports these findings, confirming that, "ESC reduces the risk of all single-vehicle crashes by more than 40 per cent-fatal ones by 56 per cent." The IIHS estimates that up to 10,000 fatal crashes (in the U.S.) could be avoided each year if all vehicles were equipped with ESC.

In the United Kingdom, the Department of Transport concludes, "That ESC equipped vehicles are involved in 25 per cent fewer fatal road accidents." From the Swedish Road Administration, "For serious and fatal loss-of-control type crashes on wet roads the effectiveness was 56.2
 
Register to hide this ad
Yes, it should be mandatory now that it's cheap enough. I think it's mandated in the US for 2012. I don't know what the GVW limit is though and if that will give 3/4 and 1 ton trucks a 'pass', I hope not.

One of our work trucks is a non-Mega '06 2wd Dodge with a Cummins. To an inexperienced drive that truck is dangerous as hell in the rain. It came with Michelin A/S tires that I consider to work well. It seldom has a load in it so I run the fronts at 60psi and the backs in the 55-57psi range. It'll spin the back end around in heartbeat if you mis-judge the turbo lag and hit the throttle a bit too hard rounding a corner. Aside from the kidney bleed ride quality the SRW 3500 is kinda fun to drive though:biggrin2: Horsepower is cool, fast etc; torque is just fun!


:cheers:
 
Falls said:
is VSC the 4R version of this ?
Yes. VSC, VSA, ESC and Stabili-trak are some of the names. The concept is the same on all of them.

If I saw the weather correctly you'll be testing your today, or maybe not, fresh Revo's are pretty nice...
 
CJ3Flyr said:
Yes. VSC, VSA, ESC and Stabili-trak are some of the names. The concept is the same on all of them.

If I saw the weather correctly you'll be testing your today, or maybe not, fresh Revo's are pretty nice...

I thinks it's a wonderful thing to have , it just needed an on/off switch which they took car of in 08.
Otherwise it also can be very dangerous in a select few instances.
 
I wonder if VSC becomes mandatory, would a disable switch then be illegal?

Perhaps for offroading, vsc disable would turn back on above a certain speed.
 
rook said:
I wonder if VSC becomes mandatory, would a disable switch then be illegal?

Perhaps for offroading, vsc disable would turn back on above a certain speed.

That's a good question.

I drive an '06 'vette sometimes. It's VSC does disable, they call it track mode. It doesn't turn back on at any speed. My Dad's Ridgeline turns it back on at 30mph IIRC.

I wonder what the '08 T4R does:confused: If I were an insurance company I would study VSC modes as carefully as top-speed and horsepower as part of my equation to quote rates.

Most of these things have black boxes too. You wreck the 'vette at 90mph in track mode and GM's defense attorneys are going to know...

:cheers:
 
Last edited:

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
278,307
Messages
3,554,054
Members
248,016
Latest member
Advally Service

Trending content

Back
Top